Skip to content Skip to navigation

Damming cloud over India’s Northeast

The Dibang movement fell silent as the Union Minstry of Environment and Forests granted clearance to the project last September after a reduction in the dam height by10 metres. After the Dibang it is now the Demwe Lower that is gathering storm in Northeast India.

The 1,750-MW Demwe Lower mega hydel project—a 124-metre high dam proposed on the Lohit, a major tributary of the Brahmaputra in Arunachal Pradesh, has almost being pushed through had it not been for the Union Tourism and Culture Ministry’s objection that was the spanner at the last moment.

Interestingly, the Union Ministry of Environment and Forests did not make any mention of the Central Tourism Ministry’s objection to the project during submission before the National Green Tribunal. However, the Tribunal took cognizance of a case filed by local stakeholders opposing the mega project and that led to the stay on the proposed project.

The Assam Government in its affidavit placed before the National Green Tribunal has admitted that the fluctuations of water flow in Lohit and its contiguous water channels in the river Dibang in the north and river Dibru in te south of the Dibru-Saikhowa  National Park will enhance and reduce the flow inside the numerous rivulets inside the Park. These channels are known for their concentration of gangetic dolphins.  However, these are not the concerns that are taken as merits for the stay in the Demwe project. Rather, it is now faith versus development. 

Religious sensitivity combined with tourism angle

Arunachal tourism claims the dam site is where Parashuram, a most ardent devotee of Lord Shiva, took a dip to cleanse himself of the sin of killing his mother at the instruction of his father with an axe that got stuck to his hand. The spot where the axe fell came to be known as Parasuram Kund,one of the most revered pilgrimage site in India with large number of devotees from across India and Nepal converging on the Kunda annually during Makar Sankranti.The site is a unique combination of cultural and biological diversity held sacred by not only the indigenous communities of Northeast India but across India, Nepal, Bhutan and Bangladesh and an important part of the international tourism circuit. The Union Tourism and Culture Ministry’s letter to the MoEF, seeking to protect the heritage, concludes:…If this project is allowed to be constructed, it will generate 23 lakh truck loads of debris, which will not only destroy the holy site of Parasuram Kunda, but also the ambience of the site, which will be converted to a dump yard.

Not only the site of Parasuram Kunda very important from cultural point of view, it is also very attractive tourist spot and the Ministry of Tourism has already sanctioned Rs.462.68 lakh to Arunachal Pradesh government for construction of a tourism complex at the holy site. This money has already been released to the state government during 2007-08 and has already been utilized by them. The construction of the Project and the dam will be disastrous for Parasuram Kunda, which is important from both cultural as well as tourism angle”.

The Arunachal BJP unit has demanded an investigation into how the Project was first allowed. It may be mentioned that the Demwe Lower project which has been hanging since 2011got a breather when Jayanthi Natarajan, the environment minister under the UPA regime, cleared it in 2012, setting aside objections of  a wildlife expert committee.

With the new regime at the Centre refurbishing the entire clearance mechanism in order to speed up the implementation of hydropower projects as well as road projects in the strategically located border state, Arunachal apparently got a major shot in the arm on the hydropower front. Last year the Centre cleared the 3,000 MW Dibang Hydropower Project. The Dibang is one of the 168 massive dams in a series of mega dams planned in the Northeast—India’s “future powerhouse”. The damming programme is highly controversial as it fails to take into account geological and ecological factors as well as impacts of climate change in the region. Further it ignores all expert and advisory committees in the attempt to tap “clean energy” 

Target set for 55,000MW by 2021

The grandiose plans of the Centre to generate 55,000MW from 160 odd dams in Arunachal is the most dreaded nightmare for downstream states as the cumulative impact of all the dams is likely to trigger catastrophic and irreversible consequences in the geologically and environmentally fragile Easter Himalayas. 

 Arunachal has plans for 44 hydropower projects with an estimated potential of 18000MW in the Siang sub basin and another 40 projects on the Kameng river basin with a combined capacity of 4,000MW. With substantial investments from big companies the state has set a target of generating not less than 40,000MW by 2021.

While Arunachal claims that the proposed projects would not only make Arunachal a power surplus state but would also meet the growing power shortage in the north eastern states, the downstream states like Assam has a different story to tell. The downstream impact of the big dams looms large over Assam. Hundreds of villages live with the nightmare of being washed away in case of any ecological disaster, the region being on a highly seismic zone. 

The Siang becomes Brahmaputra in Assam and is the lifeline for millions of people. As such the projects on Siang and their impact on the environment have received greater focus. The ever receding water in the mighty river during the dry season is a grave concern with the people of the Brahmaputra valley. Similarly, the Kameng enters Assam as Bhoreli and there are growing concerns over the environmental impact.

Protests linked to survival of indigenous communities

While the protests over big dams are basically concerned with environmental impacts, the six-year long opposition to the Dibang dam, one of the world’s tallest dams on river Dibang-- another major tributary of the Brahmaputra—was largely driven by fears of demographic change that the project would  bring with the migrant workforce. The protests were largely from the the Idu-Mishmi tribe, a community that barely has 12,000 members and scattered in the two districts spread across the Dibang basin.

The Forest Advisory Committee that examines the impact of infrastructure projects in wilderness areas earlier refused environmental clearances for the Dibang project even after several revised proposals concluding—“ecological and social costs of destroying a vast tract of forest land which is a major source of livelihood for the state’s tribal population would far outweigh the benefit likely to accrue from the project”.

Plea for environment audit

Opposition parties in Arunachal were demanding for environment audit in the state. One of the richest biodiversity zones in the Eastern Himalayan region, Arunachal Pradesh hardly has any policy initiative to protect its environment and rare wildlife.

The Dibang project alone will result in diversion of 5,056.5 hectares of forest land and felling of over three lakh trees while taking away shelter from various species protected under Schedule-1 like the rare goat-antelope species serow, goral and the Mishmi takin. Dumping of wastes into rivers and streams, uncontrolled mining, jhum cultivation and damming of rivers for hydropower generation heavily degraded the ecology of the region. 

Parties like the NCP has demanded the Auditor general for taking up audit of mega power projects in both the public and private sectors and to take into account the accumulative effects on the lives and culture of the indigenous people. 

 

Author info

Mubina Akhtar's picture

Journalist, activist based in Guwahati. Email: newildflowers@gmail.com

Add new comment

Random Stories

Dukheswar Koch remembered

22 Sep 2016 - 5:51pm | AT Kokrajhar Bureau
Rabha Sihitya Sabha and Rabha community recalled contributions of Dukjeswar Koch, founder president of All Rabha Sahitya Sabha towards literary field, on his 36th death anniversary at Magurmari High...

No trace of missing youth

17 May 2015 - 9:26am | AT News
The boy who went missing on the river Brahmaputra on Saturday is still to be rescued. NDRF officials have resumed rescue operation on Sunday on the mighty river near the Saraighat bridge. But there...

Acid test for Chief Executive Member, Haflong

30 Jun 2010 - 12:05am | Anup Biswas
The Chief Executive Member, North Cachar Hills Autonomous Council now Dima Hasao Autonomous Council Samarjit Haflong may face acid test tomorrow as several members of NCHAC are contemplating for...

Bodoland Chah Mazdoor Union extends support to BJP

2 Mar 2016 - 9:26am | Shajid Khan
The Bodoland Chah Mazdoor Union has extended its support to BJP for the coming assembly election.In a statement, the Bodoland Chah Mazdoor Union stated that they had a talk with the BJP Asom Pradesh...

Other Contents by Author

OFT, in the stilly night,Ere slumber's chain has bound me, Fond Memory brings the lightOf other days around me:The smiles, the tearsOf boyhood's years… (The Light of Other Days- Thomas Moore) As I sit down to reminisce my days in school when it completes a monumental journey of fifty years of existence—these lines come back to me bringing along a collage of pictures of different hues strewn across time. I had the privilege to have studied in a Montessori School that in course of time metamorphosed into a full fledged high school and earned the rare recognition of being the first provincialised English medium school in Assam. Kushal Konwar Balya Bhawan, as the school is presently...
Forest guards shot dead a charging adult male rhino in the Agaratoli Range of Kaziranga National Park on September 20. Earlier this year on February 14, a forest guard Gautam Barua, had to meet a terrible fate when he was on duty in the Bagori range of the National Park. He was killed by a charging rhino. In other words, the protector became the victim. Another guard, Podu Rajbongshi survived a similar attack in the Rajiv Gandhi Orang National Park in the last week of January. The year 2016 also saw similar incidents. Francis Horo, working with the forest department, died in an attack by wild buffalo on January 16 in the Bagori range of Kaziranga National Park while Sariful Islam, a forest...
The recent wave of flood in Assam left a trail of devastation affecting a total population of 33, 45,442 people and taking a toll of more than 150 lives. However, unofficial sources claim the death of more than 200 people in the recent deluge. Incessant rains since the first week of July coupled by dam-induced flood claimed 84 lives. The second bout of flood proved a disaster to the state; humans, animals including wildlife being washed away; millions of people displaced; thousands of hectares of standing crops destructed. Embankments were breached in 26 places in 15 districts. The Assam State Disaster Management Authority put the number of flood-hit people taking shelter in 923 relief...
The shrieking crescendo calls of the Koel and the flowering of ‘Kopou’ are harbingers of spring signaling the dawn of a new year in the Brahmaputra valley. The season sees the ubiquitous orchids with bright and heavy blossoms, varying in colors, bejewel the wilderness of the Northeast. ‘Kopou Phul’ is the most sought after orchid in Assam during New Year festivities in April. Assamese women adorn the pink flowers with deep pink spot as ornamentation on their head during celebration of ‘Rongali Bihu’. Found in North East as well as South India, Nepal, Bhutan, Sri Lanka, Myanmar, Thailand, Indonesia, Java and Philippines--‘Kopou Phul’ or ‘Seeta Pushpa’ in Sanskrit, Ryncostylists retusa is...
“Brahmaputra on one way sacred, one way trouble maker,” this was the observation made by the 14thDalai Lama Tenzin Gyatso in Dibrugarh during his recent tour of Assam. During an interaction programme with students of the Dibrugarh University in the University auditorium on April 3, the Tibetan spiritual leader said that due to global warming there are more glacial melt in the Himalayan ranges. “In today’s world we face increasing natural disasters, including earthquakes, due to the effects of climate change. Yesterday in Guwahati I attended the Namami Brahmaputra Festival celebrating the sacredness of that great river, but we know it also has a tendency to flood.” “Because of global warming...
The Northeast forms a complex geomorphology with vast flood plains, valleys, hills and ridges of varying elevations, beels (wetlands) and swamp areas with presence of large number of avifaunal diversity. The mighty Brahmaputra and its tributaries serve as the winter visiting ground to many migratory birds. From the marshes of Kaziranga to the forests of Eaglenest in western Arunachal and further up to the alpine areas of Arunachal -- one come across more than 750 species of birds that includes most of the winter visitors. Assam, along with the other six northeastern states, shares a common migration route for many of the avifauna that flies over Bhutan, Tibet, China, Myanmar and Bangladesh...
The Northeast forms a complex geomorphology with vast flood plains, valleys, hills and ridges of varying elevations, beels (wetlands) and swamp areas with presence of large number of avifaunal diversity. The mighty Brahmaputra and its tributaries serve as the winter visiting ground to many migratory birds. From the marshes of Kaziranga to the forests of Eaglenest in western Arunachal and further up to the alpine areas of Arunachal -- one come across more than 750 species of birds that includes most of the winter visitors. Assam, along with the other six northeastern states, shares a common migration route for many of the avifauna that flies over Bhutan, Tibet, China, Myanmar and Bangladesh...
An ideal habitat for the breeding of rhinos, Kaziranga has seen a rise in the number of the species. The animal shrugged off its ‘endangered’ tag as soon as its population crossed the 2000 mark. This fuelled an overweening strategy--the much hyped Indian Rhino Vision -- that targeted 3,000 rhinos by the year 2020 in the rhino-bearing sanctuaries of Assam. However, with the number of this pre-historic pachyderm crossing the 2,500 mark, a host of challenges also came to the fore, poaching being only one of the concerns. Kaziranga has been plagued by other challenges like-- shrinking of the habitat, encroachment of the corridors around the Park, siltation of the water bodies and a complete...
The Manas National Park and Tiger Reserve suffered huge loss as flood waters of river Beki inundated 60 per cent of the Park since the last four days. Floodwaters entered the Park breaching the embankment at Panchmile under the Bansbari Range and submerged large areas of National Park on Wednesday night. The release of waters from the Kurichu dam by Bhutan has been attributed to the untimely disaster. “The waters have receded now but have left a trail of devastation. The flood breached the embankment at three sites making the Park all the more vulnerable, besides damaging most of the roads making movement almost impossible,” Dharanidhar Boro, deputy director of the Park said. “The bridge at...
At the prestigious India Today PSU Awards 2014, the Numaligarh Refinery Limited (NRL) was awarded the ‘Most Eco-Friendly Public Sector Unit (PSU) in the Miniratna category. It was stated that the award assumes a great deal of significance since the selection process included all the 229 PSUs nationwide in the fray and is, therefore, a befitting recognition of the innovative, sincere and dedicated efforts of the company towards preservation and conservation of the ecology and the environment.A year later NRL was once again in news—this time for sending rare and Scheduled I species to death throes! The anti-conservation strategy and gross violation of environmental norms by the company drew...