Skip to content Skip to navigation

Godhra Panel Report

“There is no meeting of minds, no point of understanding with terrorism. Just a choice: Defeat it or be defeated by it.”
– Tony Blair (Former PM of Britain)

“Do not yield. Do not flinch. Stand up. Stand up with our President and fight (terrorism). We’re Americans. We’ll never surrender.”
– John McCain (US Senator)

The burning of coach no. S-6 & S-7 of Sabarmati Express at Godhra Railway Station (Gujarat) on 27th February 2002 which claimed the lives of 59 people including 25 women, 15 children and kar-sevaks returning from the kar-seva at Ram Janma Bhumi Mandir, Ayodhya, was pre-planned, the Nanavati Inquiry Commission has found. The killing of the 59 people by burning of the train triggered Gujarat-wide communal violence. The report states that about 140 litres of petrol was purchased by Razzak Kurkur and Salim Panwala to execute the conspiracy. As per the Commission’s report, Shaukat Lala and Mohammad Latika had possibly opened the sliding door connecting S-6 and S-7 coaches and entered S-6 through that door. One Hassan Lala had thrown a burning rag which had led to the fire in the S-6 coach.

This conspiracy was hatched at the Aman Guest House on the direction of Maulvi Hussain Umarji and executed by Razzak Kurkur, Salim Panwala, Shaukat Lala, Imran Sheri, Rafique Batuk and Shiraj Bala. The report concluded, “The conspiracy hatched by these persons further appears to be a part of large conspiracy to create terror and distabilise the administration”.

The findings of the Commission constituted by the Government of Gujarat in March 2002 and headed by Supreme Court Justice (retd.) G. T. Nanavati and assisted by another Justice (retd.) Akshay Mehta contradicts the findings of another panel headed by Justice (retd.) U. C. Benerjee which unequivocally stated that the fire was accidental and there was no evidence to suggest that the train carnage was pre-planned. The Benerjee panel was set-up by Railway Minister Shri Laloo Prasad Yadav. The first part of the report was tabled in Gujarat Assembly on Thursday (25th Sept. 2008) which evoked instant criticism from opponent political parties. The opposition in Gujarat Assembly was more upset to learn the report which stated, “There is absolutely no evidence to show that either the Chief Minister or any of the Ministers in his council or police officers had played any role in the Godhra incident”. The Justice Nanavati Commission has filed the first part of the two-part report. While the Commission’s terms of the reference is to probe both the fire on the Sabarmati Express at Godhra on 27th February 2002 and the post-Godhra riots that followed, the first part concentrates on the Godhra train burning. One looks forward to the second part of the report as well as the findings of the Supreme Court appointed Special Investigation Team (S.I.T.) for more comprehensive view of what happened during retaliatory mob fury in 2002 in whole of the state of Gujarat that left one thousand people killed, hundreds of houses and industries burnt and properties worth hundreds of crores of rupees destroyed, more so, the irreparable void created between both the warring communities – Hindus and Muslims. The team is supposed to file its report by December which is when the second part of the Nanavati Commission’s findings is also expected. One hopes they shed more light on Bharatvarsh’s worst religious rioting this decade.

Giving a clean chit to Gujarat CM Narendra Modi in the Godhra train carnage, the Justice Nanavati Commission said, “The kar-sevaks had not done anything and no incident had happened earlier which could have led to the incident which later on happened at Godhra”. The Godhra carnage also led to Gujarat’s first POTA (Prevention of Terrorism Act) case which booked 131 accused of whom 2 died in judicial custody and some are out on bail. Two prime accused, Salim Panwala and Farukh Bhana are absconding and presumed to be in Pakistan. The Commission holds Maulvi Hussain Umarji of Godhra as the mastermind of the train carnage.

Justice Nanavati completely dismisses the theory that a Muslim girl was attacked on Godhra railway platform provoking the attack on the train. He says, “Because the train was running late, they (Muslims) had to make some changes in their plan and circulate a false rumour regarding abducting of a Ghanchi Muslim girl. That was done in order to collect large number of persons near the train and induce them to attack it so that they get sufficient time to go near the train with petrol”. Justice Nanavati also asserts that, “the train did not stop on its own but it was made to stop by pulling the alarm chain from outsides” thus disputing the claim that chain was pulled from inside to stop the train.

The Congress, the Left and Laloo Prasad Yadav called it partisan. The Congress has described the report as a “murder of democracy”. The CPI (M) has called it “piecemeal”. Railway Minister Laloo Prasad Yadav has termed the report untrue and compared its findings with those of the Justice U. C. Benerjee Commission set up as an in-house panel by the Railway Ministry. The Benerjee report had concluded that the Godhra fire had begun inside compartment S-6 of the Sabarmati Express on 27th February 2002. The Nanavati report has, on the other hand, gone along with the findings of the police and eye witness accounts that have held that the compartment was set on fire by a frenzied mob that had gathered on the platform and, in fact, attempted to set fire to other coaches as well. Without going into an analysis of the Nanavati report, it is worth commenting on the perverse responses it has drawn from those politically opposed Gujarat Chief Minister Narendra Modi.

Not bothering to so much as study a report prepared by a former judge of Supreme Court, not caring to go into specific arguments and pointing out logical inconsistencies or flaws, the Congress – UPA and Left leadership trashed Justice Nanavati’s assessment. They have questioned the honesty and credibility of Justice Nanavati but offered no reasons for doing so. Such hit and run tactics could be expected from the familiar bunch of Left–liberal activists who have made a career of Gujarat bashing and who have said that Justice Nanavati has not “inspired much confidence”. This comes from mainstream parties that are running the Union Government. This is alarming.

Consider the hypocracy. The same Justice Nanavati enquired into the anti-Sikh violence following the assassination of Mrs. Indira Gandhi in 1984. On the basis of that Nanavati report, two Congress leaders, Shri Sajjan Kumar and Shri Jagdish Tytler, were put in the dock. Tytler was even forced to resign from the Union Government. The Congress accepted the report as did the UPA allies and Left. The cabal of professional civil right activists hailed Justice Nanavati’s dogged pursuit of the truth. In Delhi, he was a heroic judge, in Gujarat, he is an untrustworthy charlatan.

Till recent past in our country the judicial commission of inquiry had certain sanctity. It was left free of politics and its findings were debated, discussed, disputed and disagreed with – but not debunked wholesale. Even Justice M. C. Jain’s somewhat exaggerated study of the background conspiracy while going into Rajiv Gandhi’s assassination was taken seriously enough for the Congress to withdraw support to the United Front Government and force the country into an election barely 18 months after the previous one. Today, for the same party to ridicule a judicial inquiry and refuse to point out specifically which section it disagrees with, what evidence it feels has not been consulted and why it is flawed, is simply advanced applying all propaganda tactics. The Congress – UPA and the Left cannot denounce and rejec t a report simply because it doesn’t suit their political ends or doesn’t deliver the verdict they would have wanted it to. Tomorrow, the BJP – NDA could play the same game and Bharatiya jurisprudence would be the poorer for it. This is dangerous downfall of credentials of politicians, political parties and the Government. This will have demoralizing affect on legal and bureaucratic set up (judiciary and executive).

- Jagdamba Mall

Add new comment

Random Stories

Sainik School Alumni Meet

18 Feb 2011 - 4:41pm | Ranjan K Baruah
The annual day celebration of the Old Boys Association (OBA) of Sainik School Goalapara (SSG) will be held at Shilpagram, near Samkardev Kalakhetra in Guwahati on February 19 with a day long...

Five held in Kokrajhar

31 Aug 2016 - 7:23pm | AT Kokrajhar Bureau
In a major breakthrough, security forces apprehended five persons, including two militant cadres at different places within 24 hours in operations in Kokrajhar district of lower Assam. Shyamal...

Kokrajhar: BJP ups ante on PM

29 Jul 2012 - 2:53am | editor
BJP on Saturday sharpened attack on Prime Minister Manmohan Singh a day after Assam Chief Minister Tarun Gogoi blamed the Centre for delayed action to curb the violence. The party also accused the...

AAMSU burn effigies of Sonwoal, Sarma

28 Jul 2016 - 8:23pm | AT Kokrajhar Bureau
The All Assam Minority Student Union (AAMSU) irked over the state government's budget placed by Finance minister Himanta Biswa Sarma during ongoing budget session of Assam Legislative Assembly on...

Other Contents by Author

If magh bihu comes can community fishing be far behind? From early in the morning people in several places across the state are landing in community fishing a few hours before the feasting festival. Armed with the various traditional weapons, people, mostly, living near the rivers and water bodies are engaged in fishing.“It is our tradition of fishing on Uruka day. I have a good catch of fish half an hour after I landed in this water body. I need no longer to stay here,” Jiten Barman told Assam Times in Nalbari who joined the fishing early in the morning.Tridip Das a local resident of Jalukbari area is equally happy after he caught a fish during the community fishing in deepor beel, a well...
Braving a biting chill, the entire state is soaked in Magh bihu festivity on Wednesday. Every household is busy with the last minute preparations a day before the much vaunted festival of feast.Today is uruka, the day of feast festival. Shops and markets are teeming with people for last minute shopping for the evening feast. Fish, meat and vegetables are flooding in the markets from early in the morning. Apart from feast a series of cultural programmes are lined up on the occasion.After the whole night celebration, the bihu would take place on Thursday morning by liting up the wooden made meji to offer puja to the god of fire. Governor PB Acharya, chief minister Tarun Gogoi along with many...
Only a day is left for Magh Bihu, the much vaunted festival of feast and merriment. But soaring prices seem to have embittered the real taste of the festival. Shops and markets are teeming with the people for bihu shopping. But a sudden price hike makes it difficult for the common to buy the commodities in the shops and markets.“Beaten rice is available in the markets. But the price stands at Rs 60 per kg. We the common people can hardly afford cream. Price of curd, pulse, coconut and molasses are also going up,” said Ananta Saikia in Ganeshguri.Jina Devi, a housewife in Beltola told Assam Times that a tight purse has not allowed them to buy more commodities in the market. She said, “We...
The North East Research and Social Work Networking (NERSWN), an NGO of Kokrajhar base observes its 10th foundation day with two day long progrmme from Monday at Gwjwn Dera NERSWN Complex, Chnandrapara in Kokrajhar. Deputy Commissioner Themeswar Malakar inaugurated the Children’ Mela where the different types of Science Exhibition, Magic Show, Sports, Literarily and cultural by the student children displayed. Children from different schools of lower Assam participated and displayed their talent in the field of science, arts, Technologies etc.A Seminar on “Civil Society Space in Promoting peace and Reconciliation in Zone of Conflict” was also organized the seminar was...
Senior bureacrate Himanshu Sekhar Das took oath as chief commissioner of RTI on Monday. Governor JB Patnaik administered Das the oath of office and secrecy at a brief fuction at the Raj Bhawan in the morning. Chief Minister Tarun Gogoi was also present in the function.  
The Assam Government will confer Sukapha award to noted lawyer KN Saikia on Tuesday. The former Supreme Court judge will receive the award from chief minister Tarun Gogoi at a function at Rabindra Bhawan in the afternoon.       
A total of 702 tribal families were given away land pattas, covering 300 bighas of forest land under the Scheduled Tribes and Other Traditional Forest Dwellers (Recognition of Forest Rights) Act, 2006 under Chirang Forest Division at a function held at Dhunabari Lower Primary school in Chirang Tuesday. BTC chief Hagrama Mohilary handed over the papers in the presence of BTC Deputy Chief Kampa Borgoyary, Deputy Commissioner, Chirang, Virendra Singh Mittal, DFO, Chirang, Subash Chandra Brahma and Project Director Deba Kumar Kalita. BTC Speaker Paniram Brahma and former Transport Minister, Government of Assam, Chandan Brahma were also present in the meeting.
Prime Minister Dr Manmohan Singh put in his papers before the President on Saturday. Dr Singh, who represents Assam in the Rajya Sabha, rushed to president Pranab Mukherjee at the Rashtrapati Bhawan at 12.30 in the afternoon where he tendered his resignation letters. Mukherjee accepted his letter and requested Dr Singh to continue the office till the next candidate takes over as the prime minister. Dr Singh, a professor and economist and former RBI governor was inducted in the Narasimha Rao cabinet as finance minister in 1991. In 1992, he was elected to the Rajya Sabha from Assam. Later in 20 04, when the party regained power he was sworn in as prime minister. He continued the office when...
Chief minister Tarun Gogoi said that he would quit taking moral responsibility of his party's dismal show in the Lok Sabha polls. Talking to Assamtimes at his Koinadhara residence on Friday, a visibly Gogoi said that he would send his letter to Sonia Gandhi seeking her consent. Same this was what APCC president Bhubneswar Kalita said after his party was trailing behind BJP in 8 seats.