Skip to content Skip to navigation

Gross discrepancy in APSC appointments

The Assam Tribune editorial dated January 29, 2009 holds that the Assam Public Service Commission (APSC) is no exception to serious criticism for gross irregularities in holding competitive examinations, favouritism in the selection of candidates and corruption. It further says that the scandals of the Assam Public Service Commission need no reiteration.

In December 20, 2008 the Government of Assam and the Assam Public Service Commission (APSC) were issued show cause notices by the Gauhati High Court over selection of candidates for viva-voice, with a couple of non-qualified candidates, alleging favouritism and other severe irregularities in the selection process. In September 1, 2009, the Gauhati High Court scrapped the selection list of the Assam Civil Service saying that selection done by Assam Public Service Commission (APSC) was not based on merit.

As recently as November 17, 2011, the Assam Public Service Commission invited applications for (1) the post of a Principal in the State Engineering College of Assam under Higher Education (Technical) Department and (2) 16 posts for Deputy Director, Inspector of Schools and District Elementary Education Officer under Education(Secondary) Department. The first post called for a minimum of 10 years of experience in teaching/research/industry, of which at least 3 years should be in the level of a Professor of an Engineering College at the Degree level and the second required 10 years of teaching experience in a School or College or administrative experience of 10 years of which 5 years must be in teaching.

Of the many who applied the required 16 deserving candidates were selected and accordingly retained against their respective posts. In the order of their positions achieved, they were: (1) Anjan Kumar Deka (2) Jyotsna Rani Brahma (3) Prasanna Borah (4) Amir Hussain (5) Chinmoyee Talukdar (6) Subhalakshmi Rajkumari (7) Rumi Choudhury (8) Jayanta Thakuria (9) Semina Yasmin ara Rahman (10) Buli Gogoi Bhuyan (11) Saju Kumar Jadav (12) Jagadish Prasad Jadav (13) Mridul Kumar Nath (14) Anup Kumar Das (15) Jaypal Sing Brahma and (16) Gayatri Naiding.

Incidentally, credentials provided by the first candidate Anjan Kumar Deka in support of 10 years of teaching experience appear straightly forged. Deka submitted a certificate as issued from the Tihu College under Nalbari District that cite his teaching experience in the said College to be from April 1, 2005 to February 24, 2011.

Vice Principal of the College G.N. Sharma in a reply to DHE/RTI/144/2012/5 dated 17-11-2012 denied Deka's appointment as a teacher and the issuance of any kind of  experience certificate in his favor under his office. He further termed Deka's attempt as completely fraudulent. Anjan Kumar Deka was appointed temporarily as a Multi-Purpose Worker (MPW) at the Naharani Sub Centre in Sonitpur District. Prior to his appointmet as MPW by the Directorate of Health Services (DHS), Assam on March 19, 2010, Deka worked as the District Quality Manager (DQM) of the Assam Sarva Shiksha Abhiyan (Education for All Movement) in Nalbari District for sometime. Since 2010 Deka is working in the Sotiya Normal School in Sonitpur as a teacher of mathematics under the Education Research and Training Parishad of the Government of Assam.

Semina Yasmin ara Rahman whose name also appears in the list of successful candidates does not seem to have the required teaching experience. This has become certain from the experience certificate she appended that shows Ref/Letter No. as PSMS/EC/007-2011 and the date of issue as 31/12/98. Rahman passed her B.A. in the year 1994 and also happens to have parallely completed her B.Ed the same year, M.Ed in 1997 and M.A. in 1998 from Gauhati University. It calls for a detailed probe as to how she completed both her B.A. and B.Ed the same year. In 2002 when Rahman applied for a post under the Assam Sarva Shiksha Abhiyan (Education for All Movement) she mentioned her cummulative experience in teaching both in High and Middle English Schools as approximately 5 years which actually means that she does not have the complete mandatory 5 years of experience which is a prerequisite for the post applied. How did she qualify the interview, then?

Cases of contradiction do not end here. Resident of Santipur Village in Mirza, Jayanta Thakuria (M.Sc and B.Ed), s/o Ramesh Chandra Thakuria applied for the post of Assistant Teacher vide an advertisement in The Assam Tribune on 10.1.2005. He furnished an experience certificate of having taught for 5 years and 6 months at the Brindabati Das Girls' High School in addition to working at the Assam Rifles Public School. Replying to a query vide GB-EST/RTI/3/2013/2 dated 21.01.2013 Headmaster of the concerned school L. M. Choudhury refuted Jayanta Thakuria's claim and testimonials. This is a classic filmy example of identical names. Jayanta Thakuria (B.Sc) working at Brindabati Das Girls' High School since 05.08.2000 is the son of Khagen Thakuria and resident of Dakhala Village of Bijoynagar area under Kamrup Rural. The former Jayanta Thakuria fradulently posed as the latter to assume a post.

Following a case filed by Hiranya Kumar Nath and others vide WP(C) No. 4325 of 2012 dated 29.11.2012 in the Gauhati High Court, Jayanta Talukdar the former furnished his testimonials including those he used to apply for the post of Inspector of Schools.

The list of such and other antices are allegedly at the cost of those deserving candidates who could not or rather did not bribe the officials of the Commission. Most of the 16 candidates selected and duly appointed have experimented with unique methods which successfully worked towards hood winking a body like the Assam Public Service Commission which is proudly one of the oldest Public Service Commissions. APSC came into being as early as April 1, 1937 with the provision of the Government of India Act, 1935 with Mr. James Hezelett, a retired ICS officer from London, as its first Chairman.

Chinmoyee Takuldar was a candidate enlisted by the APSC as the least experienced among enterviewees with work experience that goes against the APSC prerequisites. Talukdar also refrained from applying through the expected proper channel. Despite the APSC's mandatory requirement that the applicants must be among those who exhibit uniform brilliant careers, several applicants like Buli Gogoi Bhuyan, Mridul Kumar Nath, Amir Hussain, Saju Kumar Jadav and others who passed in the third division were selected by the APSC. Even grace mark holders like Anup Kumar Das also escaped scrunity and appeared in the list of 16 successful candidates.

The Assam Service Public Commission utterly failed to provide complete Third Party Information of all the 16 candidates except for 6. In the face of such blunders and exercices of violation of norms and regulations of recruitments and appointments it remains to be seen how investigation agencies like the Central Bureau of Investigation and the Central Investigation Department plan to take into account the legal sources of income of the officials who allow such processess of appointment. Such matters have turned out to be a damper for deserving applicants and have eventually eaten into the environment of healthy competition. All said, will the APSC do something to win back the confidence of the masses and clean the muck off its image?

Comments

amardeep's picture

Can APSC ensure fair recruitment in on-going teacher recruitments? Can the Chief Minister of Assam ensure that fairness? He definitely can if he wishes. Because, these kind of nuisances are not good for any political personality.

Pages

Add new comment

Random Stories

 North-East facing Rain deficit

North-East facing Rain deficit

13 Jul 2013 - 10:06am | Peter Alex Todd
Some districts of Assam may be reeling under flood but over all there is big deficit of rainfall in the state, the rainfall also is less than the previous year during the period of June and July,...

Blood donation camp at Hojai.

8 Aug 2018 - 8:47am | Nikhil Mundra
HojaI:- As a part of Golden Jubilee Celebration one of the oldest Irrigation Scheme of Assam, i.e. Jamuna Irrigation Scheme the Officers, both Office and Field Staffs  along with their family...

I don't have IIT report: CM

28 Jun 2014 - 1:44pm | AT News
Chief Minister Tarun Gogoi said on Saturday that he is not in the possession of the IIT report on artificial floods in Guwahati. Talking to reporters in Guwahati, Gogoi said that he would ask the...

Bodo singer Dwikhrong Khunggur Basumatary no more

17 Dec 2016 - 11:55pm | AT Kokrajhar Bureau
Noted Bodo revolutionary singer and song composer Dwikhrong Khunggur Basumatary passses away suffereing from throat cancer at his Goybari village near Dotma in Kokrajhar district  on Saturday...

Other Contents by Author

Gopal Subramaniam, Judge of the Supreme Court of India and Former Solicitor General of India speaking at the Trafficking panel at the International Bar Association Annual Conference in Boston said, “A state which permits trafficking needs to be visited with economic and political sanctions, and that is really the fundamental duty of all of us as collective instruments in the legal profession.” Such is the gravity of the activity.The Anti Trafficking-in-Persons Conclave 3::Moving Forward Together on its second day today conducted a panel Prosecution, collaboration across the borders to examine the prosecution process of human traffickers in situ.After probably 60 years of crime and decades...
The third day of The Anti Trafficking-in-Persons Conclave 3::Moving Forward Together had three engaging sessions that endeavored to discuss on the partnership of Civil Society in addressing Trafficking-in-Persons, the Role of Service Providers in addressing protection of human trafficking survivors and the experiences of the Civil Society Organizations. The conclave successfully ended with the formation of a Draft Action Plan. The role of Civil Society in preventing Trafficking-in-Persons is a critical approach that needs cooperation from all actors in the anti trafficking field to be able to offer their support to other actors. An engaging participation and exchange of opinions took...
Session V: Mature Media- Responsible Response towards Human Trafficking moderated by Arijit Sen, Senior Editor, CNN-IBN followed with an interactive panel of media practitioners like Sein Win (Myanmar), Kunal Majumder, Thomas Lim, Editor, Meghalaya Times, Mrinal Talukdar, Joint Editor, DY365, Amit Patro, Editor, Sikkim Express, Syed Sajjad Ali, Editor, Indigenous Herald and Appu Gapak, Sub Editor, Arunachal Times.Describing the success of carrying stories of human trafficking in Assam, senior panelist Mrinal Talukdar, Joint Editor, DY365 said that trafficking stories does not sell in Assam because the tea one drinks is the result of the 40 lakh people who have been trafficked to Assam from...
The Government of India in the Ministry of Home Affairs, in association with the United Nations Office on Drugs and Crime (UNODC) has initiated a two year project for training of Law Enforcement Officers on human trafficking in four States, namely Maharashtra, Goa, West Bengal and Andhra Pradesh.The Anti Trafficking-in-Persons Conclave 3::Moving Forward, Session IV: huddled to explore the Lessons Anti Human Trafficking Units of Northeast India.B. R. Rana, IPS, IGP (CID), Meghalaya speaking on anti human trafficking said, “The law enforcement initiatives and the resources in place to deal with anti human trafficking are pathetically limited. That is why once in a while the Government of...
Chief Minister Tarun Gogoi in his address on the second day of Anti Trafficking-in-Persons Conclave 3: Moving Forward organized by the American Center, Kolkata and Impulse NGO Network at NEDFi House, Guwahati said, “Anti trafficking offers serious challenges whether it is in South Asia, East Asia or anywhere else. Even in Assam with borders along Bangladesh, Myanmar and Nepal the issue of trafficking is on the rise without doubt. The Government of India has shown it concerns on the matter and it is our obligation and duty to ensure that everybody lives with full dignity, every child, every woman, every individual. They must enjoy human rights and live with honor which is the basic objective...
The first Session of the Anti Trafficking-in-Persons Conclave 3 took off at Hotel Brahmaputra Ashok Conference Hall Thursday evening. The Conclave is the third in the series which seeks to explore and replicate best models to address Trafficking-in-Persons in Northeast India and its bordering countries.The Asian Centre for Human Rights identified Guwahati as the main transit point for trafficking of women from North Eastern states to other parts of the country, particularly Siliguri, Kolkata and New Delhi. According to the US State Department millions of women and children are trafficked in India annually which is a source, destination and transit country for men women and children...
The American Center, Kolkata Thursday announced the "Anti Trafficking-in-Persons Conclave 3: Moving Forward Together" in Guwahati. The Conclave will be organized in association with the Impulse NGO Network an organization which has been working to combat the problem of Trafficking in Persons in North East India for over 15 years.The two day international conclave commencing December 6 aims to establish and expand collaborative partnerships in India, Bangladesh, Nepal, Bhutan and Myanmar to prevent the exploitation of women and children and protect the victims of human trafficking, while enhancing border trade relations. The first two Anti Trafficking-in-Persons Conclaves were held in...
Keeping with the U.S.' interest in India's Look East Policy the American Center, Kolkata for the first time organized an Alumni Entrepreneurship Road Show & Mentorship Program in the city capital recently. It aims to forge a long-term relationship with the alumni of the U.S. State-Department’s professional exchange programs and encouraging young leaders and entrepreneurs.India's Look East policy was framed to cultivate extensive economic and strategic relations with the nations of Southeast Asia in order to bolster its standing as a regional power and a counterweight to the strategic influence of the People's Republic of China. Initiated in 1991, it marks a strategic shift in India’s...
The Assam Government Tuesday made a forceful plea for reopening  the Stilwell Road which is capable of handling 20-25 per cent of Sino-Indian bilateral trade. It said there is need to push for a Northeast-Kunming Trade Corridor to strengthen economies. Stilwell Road, formerly called the Ledo Roadis a 769 kilometer long route that links Northeastern India with the Burma Road, which runs from Burma to China. During World War II the Stilwell Road was used as a strategic military route. The Ledo Road was intended to be the primary supply route to China and was built under the direction of General Stilwell from the railhead at Ledo in the state of Arunachal Pradesh.Inaugurating a national...
Several environmentally ‘unfriendly’ projects in Assam and other Northeast Indian States are being touted as sustainable, receiving funds under the United Nation’s Clean Development Mechanism, wreaking havoc to the ecosystem and the people in its vicinity.A majority of such projects involve renewal energy projects like dams, solar energy projects and fugitive emission from fuel.  However, a large number of projects in Assam and North East have not yet been cleared by Clean Development Mechanism (CDM) and the 30-day window period provided by United Nations Executive Board can be used to register complaints and objections against the project, which can be scrapped if enough public...