Skip to content Skip to navigation

Indian Rhino Vision 2020 misfires: another trans-located rhino dies

An ideal habitat for the breeding of rhinos, Kaziranga has seen a rise in the number of the species. The animal shrugged off its ‘endangered’ tag as soon as its population crossed the 2000 mark. This fuelled an overweening strategy--the much hyped Indian Rhino Vision -- that targeted 3,000 rhinos by the year 2020 in the rhino-bearing sanctuaries of Assam. However, with the number of this pre-historic pachyderm crossing the 2,500 mark, a host of challenges also came to the fore, poaching being only one of the concerns. Kaziranga has been plagued by other challenges like-- shrinking of the habitat, encroachment of the corridors around the Park, siltation of the water bodies and a complete lack of protection of the watershed of Kaziranga. The conservation of rhinos in Kaziranga started almost 110 years ago but conservation seems more in jeopardy now than it was a century back! With the growth of wild life population as well as the ever swelling human habitations in and around the Park, it has become a daunting task to meet these challenges without proper advisory and practice.

Instead of dealing with the long-term conservation challenges and preservation of this unique site, the Indian Rhino Vision only went on pulling out rhinos from Kaziranga and Pobitora for translocation solely keeping in view the magic figure of 3,000 rhinos by 2020. Manas National Park, another World Heritage Site and Laokhowa and Burhachapori Wildlife Sanctuaries remained preferred destinations for the translocation of rhinos under the IRV 2020 initiative. However, translocation to these wildlife areas remains a daunting task as these sanctuaries continue to be vulnerable. Rhinos were falling prey to poachers and the slaughter and maiming of the species continued unabated. Poaching of even trans-located rhinos overshadowed the whole IRV process.

Started on April 12, 2008, IRV's translocation process came under the scanner after more than half of the trans-located rhinos to Manas fall prey to the bullets of poachers. Without adequate patrolling staff, it was a colossal task for a few people to constantly guard the animals against human rapacity. The killing of these trans-located animals since 2011 in Manas World Heritage Site triggered the World Heritage Committee to send an alarm to the state that further deterioration of protection in Manas and subsequent damage caused to key attributes in Manas may lead to de-listing Manas from the World Heritage Site list.

Even after the debacle at Manas, the IRV stakeholders did not seem to learn the basics: to tighten up the protective mechanism in the sanctuaries that are soft targets for the poachers. They even went on for a temporary band-aid effort of "trimming" horns on rhinos to be trans-located to Burhachapori and also on stray rhinos. The decision, taken at the IRV 2020 partners meeting on January 30, 2014 at the Assam State Zoo was met with strong opposition from conservationists and the state forest department was compelled to abandon the idea.

Conservationists were of the view that security assessment is a must for translocation. The Assam Environment NGO Forum said—“If the government is unsure of the security in the targeted area, in this case Laokhowa and Burhachpori Wildlife Sanctuary, then translocation should be postponed till such time as the government is confident of its security apparatus.” But the stakeholders of IRV went on with their program of translocation and sent a mother rhino with its calf to the Boma (enclosure barricaded with thorny bushes and electric fence) in Burhachapori “to ensure success of translocation” that instead became the death knell for the duo.

An official of the Assam forest department, on conditions of anonymity, said, “Rhinos endure a certain amount of stress during the translocation process. It was a terrible sight-- when after regaining consciousness-- the mother rhino wounded itself with multiple injuries each time it stumbled on the thorny barrier in the effort to free itself from captivity. Further, the mother suffered a grave cut in the ear during notching, that turned septic and the animal died a slow and painful death last March. The orphaned calf was alone since March. The trauma the calf suffered after the ordeal it had gone through during the recent floods coupled with serious stomach ailments finally brought the end to the poor animal.” The rhino calf died.

Setback for IRV

The death of the rhinos in Burhachapori has become a huge setback for the IRV 2020 programme. There were allegations that the IRV stakeholders simply washed off their hands once translocation process was over; they were never bothered about the safety of the trans-located animals. This was indeed a grave allegation. The death of rhinos not only contradicts the conservation efforts but undoubtedly overshadowed the whole IRV process.

After the debacle at Burhachapori, many conservation NGOs of the state were seen protesting against the translocation programme of IRV. They held responsible the IRV stakeholders—Assam Forest Department, The Bodoland Territorial Council, International Rhino Foundation, US Fish and Wildlife Service and WWF--- for the death of at least 13 rhinos--those trans-located from Kaziranga and Pobitora. Kaziranga Wildlife Society, Early Birds, Aranya Suraksha Samity, Green Guard, The Green Society and Centre for Conservation, Education and Research demanded the forest department to stop the translocation process at once. The NGOs allege that translocation was carried out without prior and proper security arrangement of the targeted area. There were also severe allegations of negligence towards security and health monitoring of the animals. The NGOs further demanded the government to institute an inquiry into the death of all trans-located rhinos and at once make public the post mortem report of the female rhino died in the ‘Boma’ in Burhachapori last March.

Several student organizations including the Asom Jatiyatabadi Yuva Chatra Parishad also came out to voice their concern against killing of rhinos in the name of “translocation” under Indian Rhino Vision 2020---a policy that misfired!

Comments

Angelica Ibbotson's picture

It's shocking that these rhinos are dying in the name of conservation, surely there has to be a better way to tackle the problem than this? At the same time, in Kaziranga National Park, tribal people are being extra-judicially executed and tortured, also in the name of conservation. Last year a 7 year old tribal boy was shot by park guards who have immunity to prosecution from firearms offences and are under pressure from the authorities to show they are stopping poaching by killing "poachers". This results in 'fake encounters' where innocent tribal people have been lured into the forest and killed. Not only are these gross human rights violations, it's also disastrous for conservation – if the people were arrested, rather than killed, the masterminds behind the poaching can be caught and stopped (often criminals conspiring with corrupt officials) and the innocent can be released. For more info about Kaziranga see here: http://www.survivalinternational.org/news/11522

Pages

Add new comment

Random Stories

Mission Indradhanush begins

6 Apr 2015 - 11:32am | AT News
The much waited children immunization gets underway on Monday to keep seven dreaded diseases at bay in the state.Launched under the `Mission Indradhanush, the programme in this phase covers eight...

Uriamghat: NSCN-IM under scanner

20 Aug 2014 - 11:39am | AT News
 The Assam-Nagaland border erupted in violence not because of the group clash. It’s a handiwork of NSCN(M) if the reliable sources are to be believed. According to sources available with Assam...

Chakka bandh disrupts normal transport service

7 Sep 2010 - 2:33pm | editor
A 12 chaka bandh heavily disrupts normal transport service in Assam also on Tuesday. Called by motor transport workers engaged in the unorganised sector across the country, the strike began at 6...

NSCN-KK says No to Naga peace deal

23 Aug 2015 - 12:33pm | AT News
Centre’s peace deal with NSCN(IM) runs into a hail of opposition from a number of outfits from within Nagaland suggesting that it would have hardly any impact on the restive north eastern state.NSCN...

Other Contents by Author

Absence of exchange in summer time data continues to be a major concern in managing natural disasters in the Brahmaputra basin. In a media workshop on Climate Change effects in the Yarlung Zangbo/Brahmaputra Basin organised by the Third Pole Project and Internews Earth Journalism network in Kathmandu last week, Chinese scientist Dr Yang Yong said that a major disaster could have been averted ten years back had there been proper exchange of data in place. The scientist from the Hengduan Mountain Research Institute said that scientists from China predicted flash flood on the basis of rising of water level in Yigong Zangbo river (a large tributary of Tsangpo in the east of Tibet) and...
Women of Assam weave dreams in their looms... We very often echo Gandhiji’s famous line when we talk of our age-old, indigenous silk fabric of Assam. The golden thread, which is one of the strongest, generally has a long life and has a special place in the hearts of the Assamese. Silk production and weaving are intrinsically associated with Assamese culture. Muga, is produced by the Antheraea assama caterpillar. However, climate change and pollution now pose threat to the future of this national heritage.Last October (2010) the silk growers of Lakhimpur and Dhemaji (these are the two districts where Muga is produced in large scale) suffered heavy losses. All silkworms died out due to...
Of the 34 biodiversity hotspots in the world the Northeast is home to some rare breeds of flora and fauna that could hardly be seen anywhere in the globe. Of late, a study revealed here, found that the northern region can boast of about sixty per cent of the butterflies found in the entire globe.Out of the world's15,000 odd butterflies, Assam houses more than 800 of the exotic winged variety. This is perhaps, largely due to the abundance of the entire North East India. The study also revealed that Kaziranga, famous for the unicornis, alone houses about 300 of the exotic species The worrying part is that there is a gradual decline due to deforestation and very less conservation activities....