Skip to content Skip to navigation

Remembering Panditji

Forty-four years ago on May 27 the first Prime Minister of India died in harness. About Pandit Jawaharlal Nehru, Maulana Abul Kalam Azad wrote in his autobiography: ‘Jawaharlal asked me in despair, what other alternative there was to accepting partition?……..I told Jawaharlal that I could not accept his views.’ Azad added: ‘The Muslim League had accepted the Cabinet Mission Plan, and a satisfactory solution of the Indian problems seemed in sight. Unfortunately the position changed and Mr. Jinnah got a chance of withdrawing from the League’s earlier acceptance of the Plan…… I warned Jawaharlal that history would not forgive us if we agreed to partition. The verdict would then be that India was divided as much by the Muslim League as by the Congress.’ Partition was then inevitable.

In the 1946 July election of Congress President, Maulana Azad would not accept the high office. He desired unanimous election. The contest meant fighting over the opposite issues: Cabinet Mission Plan or Mountbatten Plan? As Vallabhbhai was adamant and would not withdraw, Azad withdrew himself. In my view Azad should not have withdrawn. In the contest he was sure to be re-elected. His was an error of judgment, nay his life’s blunder. The course of history would have been otherwise. There would have been no partition.

The majority in Congress was for the Poona Formula and Meerut Congress resolution of November 1946 – the ‘Congress Formula’ vis-a-vis Cabinet Mission Plan, and strongly against partition. Azad’s Working Committee would have given an altogether different course to the events. Maulana later confessed his error. India as a whole was in no mood to accept partition. So Vallabhbhai found slender support in the Congress. There was confusion – a deadlock. The Congress was caught on the horns of dilemma. Patel had no chance. At the end Jawaharlal was found to be the missing link. He was unanimously elected July 22, 1946. This weak link soon broke down.

I am tempted to ask, why Jawaharlal, who always soared high and who was a staunch, uncompromising opponent of partition of India up to the last, at last succumbed to Mountbatten? Thou too, Brutus!……Nehru did not hold Patel’s view; on the contrary, he was radically opposed to it. In fact, Nehru admitted that ‘Partition was wrong’, but he felt that it was ‘inevitable’, and that ‘it would be wisdom not to oppose what was bound to happen’, and that ‘it would not be wisdom to oppose Lord Mountbatten on this issue’! Jawaharlal accepted defeat, surrendered totally. He ‘believed’ that his friends, the Mountbattens ‘acted in India’s interests as zealously as any India could have done’, so wrote Allen Andrews under the caption, ‘The Fantastic Mountbattens’.

My own reading is: Jawaharlal Nehru might have pleaded that, in the then compelling circumstances ‘individuals did not count’; no ‘static’ thinking would do; ‘force of rapid events’ were compelling; the Congress must take ‘dynamic decision’ in the exigency of the situation that developed; etc. That was all playing to the gallery. But the fact remains that he completely succumbed to the overtures of Mountbatten. And, as a very shrewd politician that he was, he foresaw that it was ‘wisdom’ not to range himself against Patel, the coming hero of partition and therefore to be the sole leader of Congress as soon as partition became a fait accompli: A battle for leadership! In power politics ‘wisdom’ is dictated by majority of votes. Jawaharlal Nehru was after all a ‘democratic leader’! It is an open secret that this battle of leadership and wits between Nehru and Patel continued ad nauseam until the latter made his journey to the ‘bourne from which no traveller ever returns’. Behold, the partition resolution of June 14, 1947, was passed in the A.I.C.C. – the last resolution in pre-independence Congress, by 29 votes for Patel-cum-Nehru and 15 against! (My father, Maulana M. Tayyebulla, Assam Congress President voted ‘against’.) Too many abstentions and absentees….

With all the weaknesses that every political leader has, Panditji remains the most respected, loved, adored and remembered Prime Minister.

Author info

editor's picture

Please send your comments to


nayan's picture

Nehru was responsible for partition of India. He was selfish and power hungry.


Add new comment

Random Stories

11 candidate fill nomination in Udalguri

17 Mar 2016 - 8:50pm | Shajid Khan
Altogether 11 candidates today filed nominations for the state assembly election in Udalguri on Thursday. Among them were Kamali Rani Basumatari , sitting BPF MLA of Panery,sitting BPF MLA Rihon...

Kidnapped workers still clueless in Karbi Anglong

7 Apr 2012 - 3:16am | editor
Eight labourers are still remaining traceless even 24 hours after they were kidnapped from a construction site by KPLT militants in Karbi Anglong district. Security forces are launching combing...

Diktat defied, Guwahati observes Republic Day

27 Jan 2009 - 5:43am | editor
In a fitting reply to the threats issued by militants from foreign soil, Guwahatians came out into the open on Monday to celebrate the Republic Day in various neighbourhoods.Hoisting the National...

Bargeet - in english

Sankaradeva's Bargeet translation in ebook

23 Mar 2013 - 10:21am | Sanjib Kumar Borkakoti
Srimanta Sankaradeva created a new classical school of music, known as Sankari music with his Bargît. He created new Râgas for singing the lyrics known as Bargît. These Bargîts or Great Songs are one...

Other Contents by Author

Wanna do online journalism? You can do if you are confident and workaholic. Need only an online training. We at Assam Times are ready to help you translate your dream in this roaring job. Come January 1, 2018. Register now for online course free of cost and get the advantage. Manned by a team of sharp and dedicated journos of international repute we are coming up from the new years day.  
Yet another witch hunting incident fans no less shock and anger across the on Monday two days after it came to light. The incident took place at a remote helmet in Chirang district bordering Bhutan where thr body of the victim was recovered on Saturday. Identified as Guneswar Basumatary, the local resident of Koila Moila near Dotom was believed to have been killed alleging witch craft.  According to family members,Guneswar went missing on September 16 evening he visited his relative's house at Koila Moila area. Family members lodged an FIR with Amguri PS,case number 45/2017, under section 302/201 IPC. During a search operation, police and family members recovered body in decomposed...
A local magistrate in Nagaon on Friday remanded Mithu Roy to two days police custody after the trader was produced before it in connection with the recent incident where he and his associates thrashed four former ULFA rebels who approached him for fund to feed the flood hit people.  According to allegations, he was the main culprit who hired a few local associates to beat up the youths who were raising fund.  He was arrested on Thursday as he was on the run as police arrested his three associates on Wednesday afternoon.  Meanwhile, a huge gathering in the central Assam town demanded examplary punishment of the accused youths saying that they...
A candle lighting rally was  carried out at Salakati in protest against killing of ABMSU leader Lafikul. The was organized by ABMSU and was participating by ABSU, AKRSU, bengali Federation, Santhali Student's Union and many organizations. The rally was started from Salakati anchalik Abmsu office and concluded at Railway gate. Thousands housands of activists from various student's union and civilians participated and demanded early arrests of main culprits.The ABMSU demanded CBI inquiry into Lafikul murder,arrest main culprits and provide safety and security to the persons of the region. Moinuddin Ali,ABMSU leader said that main culprits should be nabbed  as soon as possible...
United Liberation Front of Asom (Independent) said The Nagas Nation has lost a true and uncompromising Nationalist. "In the creation of Western South East Asia geographic identity with an organic soul giving hope to even the smallest nationality of the region opportunity to get just political representation amongst the family of Nations reflects his deep understanding and vision in keeping with his superb statesmanship".  Describing him as a 'Grandee' of the indigenous citizens of the WESEA region, ULFA(I) chairman Dr Abhizeet Asom in his condolence message to media said "as the Chairman of United Liberation Front of Western South East Asia, he brought an affinity amongst the...
Amid an escalating controversy over beef consumption, yet another leader has quit BJP in Meghalaya suggesting a setback for the saffron party in the pre poll political landscape.  North Garo Hills BJP president Bachu Marak pulled out of the party after the national party spokesman Nolin Kohli warned him against a beef party in Tura to celebrate the three years of the NDA government at the Centre. Marak, who pulled many people to BJP in the Congress ruled state rued in his resignation letter to state party president Sjibun Lyngdoh made it plain and simple that he would never go against the sentiment of the  Garo people for whom beef is an inevitable item at any feast. He...
A crucial meeting of BPF and AGP leadership with Amit Shah is clearing the decks for the expansion of Sarbananda Sonowal cabinet slated for April 15. Senior BJP leader Himanta Biswa Sarma along with AGP president Atul Bora, his BPF counterpart Hagrama Mohilary is meeting the BJP president in New Delhi on Monday where the entire process would be finalized. Sources told www.Assam Times that Bongaigaon legislator Phani Bhushan Chaudhury is likely to be inducted in the cabinet from AGP. Both AGP and BPF will have one each in the cabinet while BJP will have six new faces in the expanded cabinet. Those who are attending the close door meet include Hagrama Mohilary, Arul Bora, Hemant Biswa...
In a bizarre incident that triggers statewide anger and surprise, the police have arrested a top ranked officer in Dispur on bribery charges on Tuesday before recovering more than Rs 1 crore from his possession.He is none other than Kujendra Doley, the irrigation secretary who alleged to have been collecting lakhs of rupees from the contractors for releasing their bills.Acting on a complaint from a contractor, the sleuths of the vigilance and anti corruption cell caught the secretary red handed and seized an astronomical amount of money from his office locker he allegedly to pay minister Ranjit Dutta.Then Doley was taken to his residence in the city and Rs 10 lakh were seized in cash during...