Skip to content Skip to navigation

When TV journalist misuses quotes

Nellie, a sleepy village in Assam witnessed a heinous massacre in 1983 snatching the lives of thousands of Muslims. It was the time, when the Assam agitation led by All Assam Students Union reached peak and New Delhi imposed an election in Assam against the will of the indigenous people. The memory of Nellie massacre still haunts the Assamese psyche. The media revisited the Nellie story recently when former Express reporter Hemendra Narayan recently released a booklet on Nellie and its coverage 25 years ago.

And it also became the occasion for some unabashed rehashing by a journalist. A story on NDTV's portal following the release was an example of this. Nitin A Gokhale, who visited Nellie three years back, produced a column using all his old information. In fact the Senior Editor, Defence and Strategic Affairs of NDTV has copied and pasted almost 80 per cent of an article used by Tehelka three years back. His column titled 'Nellie revisited: 25 years on' uploaded on Saturday (March 1), refers to a recent visit, and describes the consequences of the carnage and its implication on today's changing demographic pattern in the state. But except for the first few paragraphs the write up on NDTV is a rehash of an earlier article written for Tehelka. In a journalistic time frame can a three years back visit be described as 'recent'? And is the closing sentence, "that's the ground reality today," therefore valid?

Horeover, the journalist used a quote (Nuruddin, who was 'then a 20-year-old having just completed his schooling in Arabic' and later 'began taking active interest in politics') and said, "Today he is the member of the Anchalik Parishad and a leader of the community." The old article (uploaded in July 2005) also described Nuruddin as the member of the Anchalik Parishad (a part of Panchyati Raj system in India). So he must have been re-elected in the Panchyat polls of Assam that took place during December and January 2007. But there is no mention about it. It simply implies that Nitin does not care about the authenticity of a quote in his column.

The NDTV editor (Nitin A Gokhale ) was communicated with his personal e-mail address as well as the official feedback format, but no response came from him till date.

Now the pertinent question that arises, whether a journalist is allowed to manufacture quotes for his write-ups those might reveal biased information? Moreover, is anyone permitted to copy and paste most of the parts of his own write up, even though the situation had been changed in three long years? Are these not a clear case of unpardonable offence by the NDTV editor, which could definitely hurt the moral and ethical values of journalism? Finally why does Northeast receive such treatment from those so-called mainland Indians all the time?

Comments

Abid Boiragi's picture

Is there any ground/section to file a suit against mis-reporting? Can NDTV be asked to make a correction for its content? . Can Tehelka sue that sly editor for plagiarism?

Pages

Add new comment

Random Stories

Assam Co goes aggressive in Nelp VII

21 Apr 2008 - 5:20pm | editor
The Assam Company Ltd (ACL) is evincing interest to strike deal with domestic and international firms for more oil and gas blocks to be auctioned under the seventh round of National Exploration...

Gogoi vents ire before Modi

16 Dec 2015 - 4:56pm | AT New Delhi
Assam Chief Minister Tarun Gogoi alleged before prime minister Narendra Modi gross injustice hours after he staged dharna in front of Parliament striking nationwide attention of his charges.  ...

Kazi Najarul Jayanti at Haflong

1 Sep 2011 - 11:56pm | Anup Biswas
To commemorate the Birth Anniversary of Rebel Poet Kazi Najarul Islam, the ‘Bangiya Sanskriti Parshad’(BSP) a literary and Cultural organization of Haflong organized cultural function at...

Brisk BTC polling in Kokrajhar

10 Dec 2020 - 11:05am | AT Kokrajhar Bureau
Kokrajhar: Around 6.9 voters in Kokrajhar district are exercise their franchise in the second phase of BTC polls on Friday. The district has 19 constituencies where 77 candidates are in the fray....

Other Contents by Author

Journalists' Forum Assam (JFA) has expressed utter dismay at the prolonged strike of newspaper hawkers in Guwahati since February 16 and urged the Press Council of India (PCI) to intervene on the matter as the agitators have directly implicated on people's right to get essential information.Taking queue from the PCI chairman Justice Markandey Katju's comment on Arunachal's recent media-deadlock, following the conflict between the Itanagar authority and media persons, that the suspension of newspapers is 'not in public interest', the JFA pointed out that similar situation is now prevailing in Assam as the hawkers have neither distributed nor allowed others to do the same inside Guwahati city...
Journalists' Forum Assam (JFA) has condemned the incident of physical assault to Anup Sharma, a city based journalist and Pronib Das, a Dibrugarh based photojournalist today by a group of unruly youths near Maguri Motapung Beel under Guijan police station in Tinsukia district.Both the journalists had gone there as a part of their training & workshop under the supervision of HICAP in association with the nature conservation organization Aaranyak. Both Anup and Pronib had gone to the Maguri Motapung Beel as part of their study assignments on Tuesday and preferred a boat ride with necessary payment to the boatmen there. However, a group of local youths prevented them from taking the boat...
Expressing grave concern over the ceasing of publications of all seven daily newspapers in Arunachal Pradesh for successive second day on Sunday, the Journalists' Forum Assam (JFA) has urged the authority to resolve the matter for the sake of thousands of esteemed readers. The indefinite shutting down of all publication houses in Itanagar, the capital city of frontier State in northeast India, came into force since February 14 in protest against the authority's anti-media ruling.The journalists based in Itanagar sat together in Arunachal Press Club (APC) on Saturday and decided to continue the movement that involved local newspapers and cable news channels. The meeting under the supervision...
All Assam Media Employees Federation (AAMEF) welcomes the recent landmark judgment of the Supreme Court of India upholding the constitutionality of the Majithia Wage Board for journalist & non-journalist media employees. The three-judge bench headed by Chief Justice P. Sathasivam and consisting of Justice Ranjan Gogoi and Justice Shivkirti Singh has dismissed all 14 petitions filed by some newspaper owners of the country. The apex court rejected all contentions of the employers including the procedures adopted by the Wage Boards for preparing the recommendations.AAMEF president Hiten Mahanta and general secretary Keshab Kalita, in a statement issued to the media, advocated for...
Most of the media persons of the city were diagnosed with various dental problems, where it was found that everyone has been using wrong brushing process and irregular cleaning of teeth. The participants in a daylong dental & oral health check-up camp & oral health awareness programme, organized at Guwahati Pres Club today, were so advised by the doctors for follow-up actions to maintain the dental hygiene.Organized by the department of public health dentistry (PHD) in association with 25th junior doctors association (JDA) of Regional Dental College (RDC) Guwahati, the camp witnessed the participation of hundred media persons.A team of over 30 doctors from the department of PHD and...
No major ailment was reported among the media persons who went for a daylong health check-up camp organized by down town hospital today in Guwahati Press Club. However, most of the participants in the health camp were diagnosed with gastrotriches, back pain and spondylitis.Over hundred participants joined in the health camp, where their BP, blood sugar and also ECG & BMD were checked in need. Doctors from different departments offered consultations to the participants. In an earlier health check-up camp, organized by the down town hospital last year, the physicians witnessed some absurd reading regarding their blood pressure and blood sugar content. However this time all the readings...
The down town hospital, which is observing silver jubilee year, in association with Guwahati Press club has organized a health check-up camp for scribes on 6 February (Thursday). The health camp, to be held at press club premises, will start at 10 am (and continue till 3 pm)."We will provide free consultations from the departments of General Medicine, Diabetology, ENT, Orthopedics, Cardiology, General Surgery, Obs. & Gynecology, Physiotherapy and Diet Counseling. Moreover free blood pressure checking, blood sugar test with ECG and BMD will also be provided in the camp," informed the hospital authority.
His Holiness 14th Dalai Lama today met the Tibet Support Group, Assam and said that the non-violent movement for freedom of Tibet will set an example for hundreds of other nations who are struggling for freedom across the globe.The 14th Dalai Lama was in Guwahati to take part in the ongoing Tibetan Art Festival, which is underway at the Srimanta Sankardev Kalakshetra in Guwhati. He appreciated the efforts of the Tibet Support Group, Assam for its continued support for the movement of millions of Tibetans in the northeastern part of India."We must continue the freedom struggle through the way of non-violence, which is the Buddhist way. It is important for us to win the struggle. If the...
His Holiness 14th Dalai Lama today met the Tibet Support Group, Assam and said that the non-violent movement for freedom of Tibet will set an example for hundreds of other nations who are struggling for freedom across the globe.The 14th Dalai Lama was in Guwahati to take part in the ongoing Tibetan Art Festival, which is underway at the Srimanta Sankardev Kalakshetra in Guwhati. He appreciated the efforts of the Tibet Support Group, Assam for its continued support for the movement of millions of Tibetans in the northeastern part of India.“We must continue the freedom struggle through the way of non-violence, which is the Buddhist way. It is important for us to win the struggle. If the...
Journalists' Forum Assam (JFA) and Arunachal Press Club (APC) have appealed to the media to exercise restrain while covering the border conflicts between the two neighbouring States in northeast India.The appeal was issued jointly today after the incident of firing by armed miscreants at Bihali reserve forest in Assam's Sonitpur district yesterday killing ten people and injuring eight others which has received wider media coverage in most of the regional media outlets including the Guwahati based satellite news channels.The tension have also mounted along the Assam-Arunachal Pradesh border areas after the incident of firing yesterday that forced the some organizations of the district to...