Skip to content Skip to navigation

Media Mission for a Forest Minister

It may be vital for many to save the endangered rhinos in Assam's celebrated parks, but for a section of the media in the Northeast, it is seemingly more important to safeguard Assam's Forest Minister.

The rhino horn is prized as an aphrodisiac and a cure for many ills in traditional oriental medicine, selling for thousands of dollars per kilogram — hence the demand. Kaziranga National Park director Suren Buragohain argues all the time: ''The poachers are equipped with sophisticated weapons. But our forest guards lack the proper arms to counter them''. Incidentally, Buragohain earns brickbats from the wildlife lovers as statistics reveal that during his term, Kaziranga has lost the highest number of rhinos in a decade.

As the director was clueless about the grave threats of rhino poaching in Kaziranga, the State Forest Minister showed an equally insensitive and callous approach to the issue, all the time preferring to ignore the matter. It finally compelled the All Assam Students' Union (AASU) to take up the cause. AASU activists staged demonstrations on February 2 in front of the forest offices in all parts of Assam to protest against the authority's ''for failing to take adequate steps to stop this heinous crime against a national treasure''.

Addressing the scribes at Guwahati Press Club on February 4, Soumyadeep Datta, director of Nature's Beckon, argued that the Forest Department of Assam had not preserved the rhino horns (with ivory and other wildlife organs) in their custody. Nature's Beckon received some vital information (regarding the number of rhino horns and other precious wildlife organs) from the Chief Conservator of Forest (Wildlife) of Assam after exercising the Right to Information Act, 2005. CCF (Wildlife) MC Malakar informed that only 1,498 horns were being preserved in the custody of the Forest Department till date, a claim many deem false. He revealed, ''We have authentic information that till 1972 , Assam's Forest Department used to sell the rhino horns. We suspect the department continued to sell rhino horns even after 1972, the year the Government of India prohibited hunting of wildlife and their trade by enacting laws.''

Poaching is a punishable offence in India with seven years of imprisonment. India is a party to the Convention on International Trade in Endangered Species (CITES) since 1976, and hence it is bound by efforts to eliminate international trade in wildlife and wildlife parts.

But the hue and cry of the concerned people of the region was not taken into consideration by a section of news agency reporters in Guwahati, who continued reporting the version of the Forest Minister. Taking his cue from the last incidence of rhino killing at Kaziranga on February 5, one senior reporter went to such extent of reporting where he described the Forest Minister as seeking a CBI enquiry into the matter. The New Delhi-based news agency, IANS, on February 5 (contributed by a Guwahati-based reporter), quoted Assam's Forest and Environment Minister Rockybul Hussain as saying: ''We want a CBI to investigate the sudden increase in rhino poaching incidents at Kaziranga.''

The question arises as to whether a journalist (or an agency) should ignore other developments in a particular situation, and whether a minister seeking an enquiry into the ministry under his charge does not point to his own incompetence. Surprisingly, the reporter missed these vital points and parroted the version of the Forest Minister, perhaps because of his ignorance. But, in reality, the minister expressed his version as ''we have no reservation against a CBI enquiry into the matter of increasing cases of rhino poaching'' in Kaziranga. Facing the heat, the Forest Minister also rushed to Kaziranga on February 6 to take stock of the situation.

A second story was differently headlined, but said the same thing. Neither reported what PTI did: ''The All Assam Student's Union (AASU) on Saturday (February 2) staged a State-wide dharna to protest against the State Government's alleged failure in checking rhino killing by poachers in the Kaziranga National Park…'' One of the stories carried by IANS never mentioned that actually an environment-centric NGO had demanded a CBI enquiry into the matter much earlier than the Forest Minister.

Likewise, the Guwahati-based reporter of AP tried to paint a rosy picture of Rockybul Hussain, while narrating that the authorities at Kaziranga deployed 100 armed guards to check the poachers. He quoted the minister as saying: ''We are alarmed at the seemingly organized poaching by gangs at the Kaziranga National Park.'' He also added in the February 6 news, ''We have decided to rush 100 armed guards to Kaziranga and to equip the existing forest guards with 200 better rifles to match weapons used by the poachers.'' In reality, the news depicted the Forest Minister in such a way that nobody needs to worry about the poaching of rhinos when Rockybul Hussain is at the helm of forest affairs in Assam!

Amazingly, the news agency AP, based in New York, avoided the public fury against the Forest Department as well as the Forest Minister rather very shrewdly. As for the particular news item, released by AP and subscribed by a number of international media outlets, a serious reader may find it as a cleverly moulded piece by an experienced (and loyal) public relations official on behalf of his master! Well, if a journalist turns into a PR personnel in his approach, even a child in today's world can understand that it is not without personal gain or vested interest. A legitimate question that might arise here is whether a reporter has the right (under the Indian constitutional provision) to project a development with his own personal point of view that could even degrade the entire episode of saving the endangered rhinos just to safeguard Assam's Forest Minister.

Comments

prarthana Gogoi's picture

Undoubtedly it is a sensitive topic and sensitive, reasonable cry of Mr Thakuria, Nature’s Bacon & ASSU. Mr Thakuria is analyzing logically the report of the vested interest. But all protest should not end after the hue and cry. Thanks to Mr Thakuria for his protest in pen and paper. Why not all media of Assam (including the national and international news agency) fight against this tragedy of Kaziranga?

Pages

Add new comment

Random Stories

Relief for HSLC patients

17 Feb 2013 - 9:31pm | Koushik Hazarika
In a major relief, Education Minister Dr Himanta Biswa Sarma announced that the HSLC examiniees who have taken ill in the food poisoning incident need not appear Monday's examination. Dr Sharma...

Farmer upset, kills self

18 Oct 2015 - 9:45pm | AT News
Amid traditional religious fervor of Kati Bihu, a poor farmer in Nalbari district committed suicide on Sunday sending shock and anger across the state.Identified as Dibakar Kalita, the 48-year-old...

Huge turn out in Koliabor

7 Apr 2014 - 5:38pm | AT News
Voting has come to an end in Koliabor constituency as soon as the clock struck 5 in the afternoon. The turn out has crossed 75 per cent. The fate of 13 candidates are sealed in the electronic voting...

16 injured in Tinsukia blast

8 Mar 2008 - 8:36am | editor
As many as sixteen people have been injured while a powerful bomb exploded in Tinsukia town at around 1 pm on Saturday. According to information, the blast took place at the busy GNB Road in front of...

Other Contents by Author

The DoNER minister P. S. Ghatowar, while appreciating the role of media in India, criticized a section of newspaper and news channels for their exaggerated news with an imposed views and also unwanted role of journalists as ‘fortune-teller’ in the time of elections. The soft-spoken politician from eastern Assam also highlighted about the limitation of resources faced by the working journalists in the State. “The journalists and other media employees deserve necessary support and care from the managements and the society in general. We should extend our supports to the media persons such that they can reciprocate it for the growth of our nation,” Ghatowar, also a...
Journalists’ Forum Assam (JFA) expresses serious concern at the mysterious death of journalist turned advocate Deva Kumar Das following the simple injury by a stray leopard in Guwahati on January 7. Deva Das with two others were wounded by the leopard in broad day light, as it got panicked while trapped in a residential area adjacent to Navagraha hills at Silphukhuri locality on Saturday. All the injured were admitted to hospital, where Deva Das was given first-aid and released by the attending doctors. But next morning Deva Das, 49, was found dead at his residence. A bachelor by choice Deva Das stayed alone with some renters in the building and the door of his room was not locked...
The Asia Pacific Forum of Environmental Journalists (APFEJ) has expressed concern at the ongoing construction of a number of hydroelectric dams in Brahmaputra inside Tibetan region of China. The umbrella organization of environmental journalists based in Asia Pacific region argues that once the dams on the 2,900 km long trans-boundary river will be commissioned, there will be massive ecological affect in northeast India and also in Bangladesh. Moreover, if the government at Beijing diverts some volume of water from Brahmaputra, Bangladesh will be severely affected, as the saline water of Bay of Bengal will enter to south Bangladesh and destroy the aquatic life and agricultural field. The...
The GNRC Hospitals in association with Guwahati Press Club has announced the GNRC Media Fellowship, where the working journalists will be selected for financial support to study the healthcare situation in Assam and northeast India. Three fellows will be selected for the three month long fellowship program. Each fellow will get Rs. 10,000 per month, said Dr NC Borah, the CMD of GNRC Hospitals. Interested member-journalists are requested to send their applications with a passport size photograph, a brief profile and a note of 500 words narrating why (s)he is interested in the said fellowship program to the office of Guwahat Press Club, Ambari, Guwahati on or before January 25, 2012. The...
A press meet under the banner of Friends of Arunachal is organized at Guwahati Press Club tomorrow at 2 pm. The meeting will discuss various aspects relating to the ongoing protest against the big dams planned in Arunachal Pradesh. As the movement has gained momentum, there is increasing apprehensions that the common people of Arunachal might get confused it as an anti-Arunachali campaign. While condemning the attitude of NHPC, New Delhi, Dispur and Itanagar, the meeting will find space for maintaining cordial relationship between the people of Assam and Arunachal Pradesh.
Nikhilesh Barua, a senior music composer, documentary producer and author of Assam, will attend the next ‘Guest of the Month’ program of Guwahati Press Club (GPC) on December 27. The program will start at 1 pm. Member-journalists are requested to participate in the program.
A general meeting of Electronic Media Forum Assam (EMFA) is convened at Guwahati Press Club on January 2. The meeting, starting at 1 pm, is expected to finalize the programs of EMFA Awards 2011 in the month of February. Meanwhile, the EMFA has invited the entries of the award, where the best television news and programs, telecast between January 1 to December 31, 2011, will be awarded.
Various speakers at a consultation meeting on human rights in New Delhi emphasizes for a stronger and affective national network to pursue the movement for defending legal human rights. Reposing faith on the judiciary of India, most of the speakers argue that a systematic attack has been perpetuated by the authority and the situation is turning bad to worst. They have also insisted that National Human Rights Commission (of India) should be empowered to take timely actions to upheld the rights of the citizens of the country. Some speakers also advocated for enlightening the Press Council of India to properly monitor the activities of a section of newspapers that manufacture news with...
A new monthly magazine named Women’s Panorama was launched on 11-11-11 at Guwahati Press Club. Published by the Shillong based Eastern Panorama group of publications, Women’s Panorama is the first comprehensive magazine (English) dedicated for the woman of northeast India. Inaugurating the first issue (November 2011) of Women’s Panorama, eminent film maker from Assam, Manju Bora expressed hope that the magazine will emerge as a trusted platform for all walks of women in the region. The award wining film director and also an acclaimed author, Ms Bora however rejected the conventional idea of a woman magazine to be confined to some recipes, make-up and fashion tips. She...
Eastern Panorama group of publications, Shillong has expressed its profound grief at the demise of Dr Bhupen Hazaika, the legendary cultural icon of our country. Paying the heartiest tribute to the versatile genius, the house of Eastern Panorama had postponed the launching of Women’s Panorama, which was earlier scheduled for November 7, 2011. The monthly magazine will now be inaugurated on November 11 (Friday). The eminent film maker Manju Bora will grace the occasion as the chief guest. She will be assisted by the Women’s Panorama editor Sonata Dkhar and editor-in-chief Harsh Jhunjhunwala at the auspicious occasion. The function will begin at 3 pm in Guwahati Press Club...