Skip to content Skip to navigation

Phir Mile Sur a big disappointment

Mile Sur Mera Tumhara, the iconic anthem written by Piyush Pandey with which thousands of Indians of a particular generation grew up, had recently been re-shot in a new avatar. The new version was released in Mumbai on Republic Day earlier this week. The popularity of the original version of this anthem cannot be gauged in words as it was highly successful in generating patriotic fervor among the masses. The original video featured some of the most popular Indians of that era, like Amitabh Bacchan, Mithun Chakraborty, Jitendra, dancer Mallika Sarabhai, cartoonist Mario Miranda, filmmaker Mrinal Sen, Sunil Gangopadhyay, author Annadashankar Ray, singers Bhimsen Joshi, M Balamuralikrishna, Lata Mangeshkar, Suchitra Mitra and sportspersons Narendra Hirwani, S Venketaraghavan, Prakash Padukone, amongst many others. The sweet melody of the original version, coupled with the different tunes and ragas incorporated from various parts of the country, made one instantly feel proud of the country. The initiative to bring out the video in a completely new avatar to suit contemporary needs is indeed a commendable initiative as it is time to rouse those feelings of patriotism once again in the hearts and minds of our countrymen. However, I was greatly disappointed when I watched the new version of this anthem, Phir Mile Sur, which has been composed by Louis Banks and which features a host of artistes from the entertainment world. Incidentally, Louis Banks had also composed the original 1988 version along with late P Vaidyanathan. The celebrities which feature in the new video are Amitabh Bacchan, his son Abhishek and Aishwarya Bacchan, Ranbir Kapoor, Deepika Padukone, Shilpa Shetty, among many other personalities from all walks of life. Basically, I could not find any sense of rhythm or melody in the new song. There was no flow as such and the whole song had well-coordinated stretches which were incorporated in a haphazard manner. It is a big disappointment and I feel they would have done better had they stayed even somewhat closer to the original concept. I am also distressed at the way the video has been picturised. Has India today become limited only to Bollywood? This is what one feels after watching the video, which has celebrities from Bollywood being the sole representatives of the Indian spirit. The Northeast again has been totally left out of the picture with its only representative being a failing, old Bhupen Hazarika humming a Bengali number. While this is definitely an issue that needs to be taken up by our intellectuals and learned people, we should also start thinking as to how many people from the region have actually achieved something to have merited a place in the video in the first place. All in all, a big disappointment. Both the video and also our Indian culture, if it has indeed become what the video depicts it to be.

Comments

vickylilani's picture

I am very disappointed when I saw song & they have removed the Sindhi sentence. The old one is gold one.
omkar's picture

Yes, I am totaly agree with these.
atonu's picture

Sorry to know about it. There certainly many more important personalities to be shown in the video than the bollywood artists. Moreover Assam and the North East certainly needs better representation.
nagendra sarma's picture

Certainly the earliar verson was excellent. Really I am also disappointed.
Pallavi Barua's picture

With more and more developments in the field of sound technology in studios, creativity is losing out. To prove this statement, the latest 'Phir mile sur' is the best example as of now. And, let me say boldly, we are also DISAPPOINTED with Bhupen Hazarika in this version.
Dorika's picture

Not only creativity, there is a Loss of Soul by heavy dependency on technology in today's music and lyrics. New 'phir mile sur' is below standard.
jtapan's picture

Otherwise there wouldn't have been a phrase 'old is gold'. As for Bhupen Hazarika, as pallavi baruah has stated, we cannot be dissapointed with him butfeel sorry for him. He can hardly utter his own name properly. He has grown too feeble with age and ill health. And regarding the 'representation of the north east factor', when was there the north eastern states beyond kolkata? We have always been unrepresented. Just for that chicken neck are we calling we are part of India.It's time that the people of this region come together and raise our voice. A Good debate should be initiated in the national news channels.
raktim baruah's picture

yes it is heartening.But we have to compromise with the ebb and flow of time.
Pallavi Barua's picture

The views are entirely personal. I respect everyone's opinion over the issue and in no way feel that everyone has got to have the same views. That's it and here it ends.
Shashi's picture

I agree entirely. Its almost as if there are no other worthy people in this country except performing artistes, esp of the popular stream. N-E gets a raw deal. South is a mere 2-bit act..again making me feel as i were from a different country called 'South India' (Im sick of the ques 'are you a south indian?') Where are the sportspersons, educationists, scientists, local musicians and more importantly where is the 'aam aadmi'? Unfortunately aam aadmi only gets to be the bye-stander. And did you notice the way certain bits in the video were shot? SRK, whats-his-name kapoor and a couple others standing at the edge of some precipice or the other and spreading their arms into the air almost as if they were pleading for help! :-)
dibyashnataa's picture

I still have the (g)old song with me which i proudly play it on my phone and it has been taken by so many of my friends through the bluetooth. I AM ABSOLUTLY DISSAPOINTED to see the new video. It so commercilised, the feelings looks fake and more professional, not like the previous one, in which it seemed everyone sang from heart, headstraight, pride oozing... The old sang had already neglected north-east. just show casing a whole big society in a line without making them sing in their language is the highest sign of disrespct. The new song did not live up to the expection. And why Mr. Bacchan and his beta-bahu, has India today have no other to promote its national integration... hope we dont get see this kinda avatar... After all dont let not all be KAANTA LAGA.. Keep few things as MILE SUR MERA TUMHARA.
Jayanta Deka's picture

"Phir mile sur"... I truly agree that it is all but disappointment and the way the video is pictured, it seems like "family drama" of some stars! Funny and more so about the representation of NE!

Pages

Add new comment

Random Stories

All Assam Mamoni Bora and Dulu Hazarika memorial badminton Competition ends

29 Jan 2012 - 1:54am | Anup Arandhara
The All Assam Mamoni Bora and Dulu Hazarika memorial invitation day-night prize money badminton competition held at Gaurisagar on January 27 concluded. The winners of this competition are, Rajib...

Tulsi Vivah marks start of wedding season

1 Nov 2017 - 11:02am | Nikhil Mundra
Tulsi Vivah was  observed in Hojai with traditional Hindu fervour in many households on Tuesday. The people worshipped Tulsi Plants after it was dressed in  traditional attire to mark...

Gogoi announces 2 new forces

28 Jun 2014 - 1:37pm | AT News
Chief Minister Tarun Gogoi said on Saturday that the government has a plan to raise two separate forces to protect and preserve  wetland and hills areas. Addressing a press conference in Dispur...

Gogoi, Kalita to talk to Sonia

5 Jul 2014 - 9:17pm | AT News
Chief Minister Tarun Gogoi and APCC president Bhubneswar Kalita are understood to have been preparing to urge Sonia Gandhi to resolve the dissidence within the Congress legislature party.Both Gogoi...

Other Contents by Author

Nowadays art is an emerging market all around the globe. Economists look at this as a smart investment due to its excellent financial rewards. Although there is some awareness about it in our country, it is prevalent in only a few metro cities. To promote the art and the awareness of this investment, leading art website www.livelyculture.com organized a seminar. Many eminent persons of the State, like Hiren Bhattacharyya, Hare Krishna Deka, D.N Saikia, Jevin Gosh Dastidar, Dilip Bora, Kishore Bhattacharyya, Dilip Tamuly and many more participated in this seminar. A representative of the venture, Indrani Khaund presented a brief view on the topics. According to her Art is one of those few...
As per its tradition, Talim staged its annual group performance in Rabindra Bhavan last Sunday. Talim was founded by Sitar maestro Hem Hazarika in 1995 to keep alive the fast dying guru-sishya parampara of the country. Unlike other schools of music which lay more emphasis on certificates and degrees, Talim is one institute which believes in the acquisition of musical knowledge in a holistic manner. I remember Hem Hazarika telling me in one of our many discussions, “Merit cannot be judged with certificates. It shows when you perform on stage.” In Talim, students are not taught new lessons until and unless they have mastered the fundamental knowledge of taal and loy. Though most...
Nature had been kind to Assam, evident in its rich natural beauty. Apart from adding colours to the scenic beauty of the State, nature has also worked its charm on the creative urges of many a writer, poet and artist. And now noted novelist Swarna Bora has come up with an enchanting tale on the lives of the people residing in a village of historical significance along the Buridihing River in Dibrugarh district. Veteran novelist Phanindra Kumar Deb Choudhury formally released the book, Buridihingor Moupya aru Acharya in Guwahati recently. The writer Swarna Bora says that rivers have attracted him ever since childhood and most of his novels are based on the lives of people living on river...
When the going gets tough, the tough gets going, so sang Billy Joel. But when the going really gets tough, life tends to get disheartening, discouraging and everyday seems like drudgery. But once you make that breakthrough, you derive power in the truest sense of the term. Meet Professor Minoti Borthakur, who has not only proved the relevance of these words but is encouraging disheartened people to start dreaming and hoping once again. Minoti’s story is one of courage and determination as she dared to fight a cunning and baffling disease like cancer, even when all doctors had given up hope, and emerge victorious. And in the process, she has set an example for others with her immense...
HIV/AIDS is the biggest scourge to ever confront mankind and drugs weaken a person emotionally, physically and spiritually. HIV/AIDS is not transmitted by holding hands or by sharing food items. The younger generation, who are more susceptible to these twin threats, should take care to remain away from drugs and take all precautionary measures against possible infection by the HIV. Yours truly, along with countless other Indians (who have had the chance to attain elementary education), has been subject to this kind of a statement ever since I entered school and then, in my professional life. Still, incidents of drug abuse and HIV/AIDS cases are found to be continuously on the rise. It...
Robert Zimmerman, better known as Bob Dylan, has probably never been to Shillong. In his half-a-century old musical career, quite a few birthday parties thrown in his honour worldwide. 35 of such event have been held in the quaint little town of Shillong as the Bob Dylan fest is held in the hill city May 24 every year. It started out as a small private celebration by Lou Majaw - lead singer of the Ace of Spades band and his friends in 1972 and grew into an annual event in Shillong, drawing fans from across the country and the world. On the motive behind the Dylan fest, quintessential Khasi-guitarist, Lou Majaw says, “I’ m not star struck. But from the first time I heard Dylan,...