Skip to content Skip to navigation

13 Years After: Waiting for Justice in the Parag Das Assassination Case

x

Error message

  • Notice: Undefined index: DraggableCaptchaAnswer in draggable_captcha_generate_refresh() (line 197 of /home/assam1/web/assamtimes.org/public_html/sites/all/modules/draggable_captcha/draggable_captcha.module).
  • Notice: Undefined index: DraggableCaptchaCodes in draggable_captcha_generate_refresh() (line 197 of /home/assam1/web/assamtimes.org/public_html/sites/all/modules/draggable_captcha/draggable_captcha.module).
  • Notice: Trying to access array offset on value of type null in draggable_captcha_generate_refresh() (line 197 of /home/assam1/web/assamtimes.org/public_html/sites/all/modules/draggable_captcha/draggable_captcha.module).
  • Notice: Undefined index: DraggableCaptchaAnswer in draggable_captcha_generate_refresh() (line 197 of /home/assam1/web/assamtimes.org/public_html/sites/all/modules/draggable_captcha/draggable_captcha.module).
  • Notice: Undefined index: DraggableCaptchaCodes in draggable_captcha_generate_refresh() (line 197 of /home/assam1/web/assamtimes.org/public_html/sites/all/modules/draggable_captcha/draggable_captcha.module).
  • Notice: Trying to access array offset on value of type null in draggable_captcha_generate_refresh() (line 197 of /home/assam1/web/assamtimes.org/public_html/sites/all/modules/draggable_captcha/draggable_captcha.module).
  • Notice: Undefined index: DraggableCaptchaAnswer in draggable_captcha_generate_refresh() (line 197 of /home/assam1/web/assamtimes.org/public_html/sites/all/modules/draggable_captcha/draggable_captcha.module).
  • Notice: Undefined index: DraggableCaptchaCodes in draggable_captcha_generate_refresh() (line 197 of /home/assam1/web/assamtimes.org/public_html/sites/all/modules/draggable_captcha/draggable_captcha.module).
  • Notice: Trying to access array offset on value of type null in draggable_captcha_generate_refresh() (line 197 of /home/assam1/web/assamtimes.org/public_html/sites/all/modules/draggable_captcha/draggable_captcha.module).
  • Notice: Undefined index: DraggableCaptchaAnswer in draggable_captcha_generate_refresh() (line 197 of /home/assam1/web/assamtimes.org/public_html/sites/all/modules/draggable_captcha/draggable_captcha.module).
  • Notice: Undefined index: DraggableCaptchaCodes in draggable_captcha_generate_refresh() (line 197 of /home/assam1/web/assamtimes.org/public_html/sites/all/modules/draggable_captcha/draggable_captcha.module).
  • Notice: Trying to access array offset on value of type null in draggable_captcha_generate_refresh() (line 197 of /home/assam1/web/assamtimes.org/public_html/sites/all/modules/draggable_captcha/draggable_captcha.module).
  • Notice: Undefined index: DraggableCaptchaAnswer in draggable_captcha_generate_refresh() (line 197 of /home/assam1/web/assamtimes.org/public_html/sites/all/modules/draggable_captcha/draggable_captcha.module).
  • Notice: Undefined index: DraggableCaptchaCodes in draggable_captcha_generate_refresh() (line 197 of /home/assam1/web/assamtimes.org/public_html/sites/all/modules/draggable_captcha/draggable_captcha.module).
  • Notice: Trying to access array offset on value of type null in draggable_captcha_generate_refresh() (line 197 of /home/assam1/web/assamtimes.org/public_html/sites/all/modules/draggable_captcha/draggable_captcha.module).
  • Notice: Undefined index: DraggableCaptchaAnswer in draggable_captcha_generate_refresh() (line 197 of /home/assam1/web/assamtimes.org/public_html/sites/all/modules/draggable_captcha/draggable_captcha.module).
  • Notice: Undefined index: DraggableCaptchaCodes in draggable_captcha_generate_refresh() (line 197 of /home/assam1/web/assamtimes.org/public_html/sites/all/modules/draggable_captcha/draggable_captcha.module).
  • Notice: Trying to access array offset on value of type null in draggable_captcha_generate_refresh() (line 197 of /home/assam1/web/assamtimes.org/public_html/sites/all/modules/draggable_captcha/draggable_captcha.module).
  • Notice: Undefined index: DraggableCaptchaAnswer in draggable_captcha_generate_refresh() (line 197 of /home/assam1/web/assamtimes.org/public_html/sites/all/modules/draggable_captcha/draggable_captcha.module).
  • Notice: Undefined index: DraggableCaptchaCodes in draggable_captcha_generate_refresh() (line 197 of /home/assam1/web/assamtimes.org/public_html/sites/all/modules/draggable_captcha/draggable_captcha.module).
  • Notice: Trying to access array offset on value of type null in draggable_captcha_generate_refresh() (line 197 of /home/assam1/web/assamtimes.org/public_html/sites/all/modules/draggable_captcha/draggable_captcha.module).
  • Notice: Undefined index: DraggableCaptchaAnswer in draggable_captcha_generate_refresh() (line 197 of /home/assam1/web/assamtimes.org/public_html/sites/all/modules/draggable_captcha/draggable_captcha.module).
  • Notice: Undefined index: DraggableCaptchaCodes in draggable_captcha_generate_refresh() (line 197 of /home/assam1/web/assamtimes.org/public_html/sites/all/modules/draggable_captcha/draggable_captcha.module).
  • Notice: Trying to access array offset on value of type null in draggable_captcha_generate_refresh() (line 197 of /home/assam1/web/assamtimes.org/public_html/sites/all/modules/draggable_captcha/draggable_captcha.module).
  • Notice: Undefined index: DraggableCaptchaAnswer in draggable_captcha_generate_refresh() (line 197 of /home/assam1/web/assamtimes.org/public_html/sites/all/modules/draggable_captcha/draggable_captcha.module).
  • Notice: Undefined index: DraggableCaptchaCodes in draggable_captcha_generate_refresh() (line 197 of /home/assam1/web/assamtimes.org/public_html/sites/all/modules/draggable_captcha/draggable_captcha.module).
  • Notice: Trying to access array offset on value of type null in draggable_captcha_generate_refresh() (line 197 of /home/assam1/web/assamtimes.org/public_html/sites/all/modules/draggable_captcha/draggable_captcha.module).
  • Notice: Undefined index: DraggableCaptchaAnswer in draggable_captcha_generate_refresh() (line 197 of /home/assam1/web/assamtimes.org/public_html/sites/all/modules/draggable_captcha/draggable_captcha.module).
  • Notice: Undefined index: DraggableCaptchaCodes in draggable_captcha_generate_refresh() (line 197 of /home/assam1/web/assamtimes.org/public_html/sites/all/modules/draggable_captcha/draggable_captcha.module).
  • Notice: Trying to access array offset on value of type null in draggable_captcha_generate_refresh() (line 197 of /home/assam1/web/assamtimes.org/public_html/sites/all/modules/draggable_captcha/draggable_captcha.module).
  • Notice: Undefined index: DraggableCaptchaAnswer in draggable_captcha_generate_refresh() (line 197 of /home/assam1/web/assamtimes.org/public_html/sites/all/modules/draggable_captcha/draggable_captcha.module).
  • Notice: Undefined index: DraggableCaptchaCodes in draggable_captcha_generate_refresh() (line 197 of /home/assam1/web/assamtimes.org/public_html/sites/all/modules/draggable_captcha/draggable_captcha.module).
  • Notice: Trying to access array offset on value of type null in draggable_captcha_generate_refresh() (line 197 of /home/assam1/web/assamtimes.org/public_html/sites/all/modules/draggable_captcha/draggable_captcha.module).
  • Notice: Undefined index: DraggableCaptchaAnswer in draggable_captcha_generate_refresh() (line 197 of /home/assam1/web/assamtimes.org/public_html/sites/all/modules/draggable_captcha/draggable_captcha.module).
  • Notice: Undefined index: DraggableCaptchaCodes in draggable_captcha_generate_refresh() (line 197 of /home/assam1/web/assamtimes.org/public_html/sites/all/modules/draggable_captcha/draggable_captcha.module).
  • Notice: Trying to access array offset on value of type null in draggable_captcha_generate_refresh() (line 197 of /home/assam1/web/assamtimes.org/public_html/sites/all/modules/draggable_captcha/draggable_captcha.module).
  • Notice: Undefined index: DraggableCaptchaAnswer in draggable_captcha_generate_refresh() (line 197 of /home/assam1/web/assamtimes.org/public_html/sites/all/modules/draggable_captcha/draggable_captcha.module).
  • Notice: Undefined index: DraggableCaptchaCodes in draggable_captcha_generate_refresh() (line 197 of /home/assam1/web/assamtimes.org/public_html/sites/all/modules/draggable_captcha/draggable_captcha.module).
  • Notice: Trying to access array offset on value of type null in draggable_captcha_generate_refresh() (line 197 of /home/assam1/web/assamtimes.org/public_html/sites/all/modules/draggable_captcha/draggable_captcha.module).

"We have waited thirteen years, another hour should not be to difficult to bear, will it?" said an elderly bystander to a colleague, as all of us waited to hear the verdict of the Central Bureau of Investigation (CBI) charge sheet filed in the Kamrup District and Sessions Court, against the surviving accused in the Parag Kumar Das assassination case. The premise of the court was packed with media persons, lawyers, human rights activists, and police personnel. Among the crowd were nervous supporters of the accused who had regulation crew cuts, wore trendy shoes, jeans and white shirts. A narrow path leading to the court separated them from Parag Das’ well wishers and friends, and for an illusionary moment, the possibility of violence – should the accused be found guilty – hung over the balmy, overcast Guwahati morning. A few minutes later, the accused – Mridul Phukan – walked out with a nervous smile on his face, even as waiting news anchors frantically whispered, "Khalas, khalas" (or, "finished, finished") to their newsrooms. After thirteen years, the only surviving accused in the murder of Assam’s foremost activist and public intellectual, walked into the arms of his edgy friends and into a black SUV that whisked him away. He could afford to smile because the CBI was unable to present enough evidence to indict him in a murder that took place in full public view.

In the afternoon of May 16, 1996 as Parag Das was bringing home his young son from school in Chandmari, Guwahati, he was assassinated by four men. An unassuming, erudite man, Das was one of the founders of the human rights movement in Assam and a tireless activist who fought for the rights of the indigenous peoples of Northeast India. Before he found his calling as a rights activist and radical journalist, Das was the manager of the Guwahati Stock Exchange. His public execution in broad daylight elicited outrage in Northeast India. The four accused of assassinating Das were surrendered members of United Liberation Front of Assam (ULFA), who formed the core of the "secret killings" strategy, comprising certain members of the security forces and surrendered militants that created terror in Assam from 1996 until 2001.

In 2001, the CBI filed its charge sheet on the assassination to the court. Human rights activists expressed concern, stating that key witnesses were not interviewed; some were intimidated; and material related to the case were tampered with to ensure that there were enough loopholes that would acquit the accused and cover up the role of the state machinery in Parag Das’ murder. Furthermore, two of the accused – Diganta Baruah and Tapan Dutta – were killed before the CBI filed its charge sheet. A third, Nayan Das, was hacked to death by an irate mob in Dibrugarh in 2003. Hence, Mridul Phukan had become the central figure in a story that continues to haunt the memories of an entire generation in Assam.

"I remember I had just finished taking an exam and heard that Parag Das had been killed", said Rasel Hussain, holding back his anger and outrage outside the court. He spoke of how he went to see Das’ body in the Guwahati Medical College; seeing politicians and prominent people beating their heads in apparent anguish and crying about the death of a dream in Assam. For Rasel, the outrage was not about the acquittal but for the insidious manner in which a pliant middle class had bartered Parag Das’ ideals for money and power. Everything had changed in the last thirteen years, he felt. Yet, it was frustrating to acknowledge that nothing had changed inasmuch as the Indian state apparatus’ continuous refusal to address the deep sense of injustice that the people of Assam feel. Parag Das therefore, is a symbol of a region and its people’s dreams of justice, said Rasel.

Such dreams of justice have to confront the crassness of reality, sometimes across a narrow pathway in the Kamrup District and Sessions Court. His companions with bloodshot eyes garlanded Mridul Phukan and before a stunned public could react, they had muscled him out of the court. "There you go", said Orup Koch, as caustically as possible. "Indian democracy at its best: where murderers are garlanded and set free as a reward for serving the oppressors", he added.

One is sure that we have not heard the last of this case. Tonight, a handful of nervous SULFA men will drink in some unfortunate dive along National Highway 37; a few bureaucrats, police officials, army personnel and politicians, will fret and wonder about the next time that the Indian judicial process is called to redeem itself and if they would be safe then. As various civic organisations extend their support for a general strike called by Manab Adhikar Sangram Samiti (MASS) on July 30, 2009, the assassination of Parag Kumar Das and the manner in which the Indian state has acquitted itself, will go down as another day in the democratic polity of India, where perpetrators celebrate legal verdicts that perpetuate lawlessness and injustice.

Sanjay (Xonzoi) Barbora
July 28, 2009: Guwahati

Comments

Simanta's picture

If Law is made by men, it can be unmade by public too. Why didn't the public bash up Mridul Phukan outside the court? That would have been the best form of Justice: Public Bashing.
milk talukdar's picture

Justice?? Is it the judicial system that offering us justice??! We need a change. We need more people like Parag! After his brutal killing, all the friends of Parag who once supported him keeping themselves silent, due to afraid of bullet. It is their so called Assam loving attitude. History will not forgive you. Mind it.
Mahendra Bhuyan's picture

If Indian juditial system fail to condemd the main accuage of Parag Da case then all Indian now in last position to reviwe our juditial system. And the policy maker should take positive ontiative only because of mantain faith and trust of Indian Constitution.
Pallavi Barua's picture

The public is blaming the Law, the Constitution, the Judiciary, Mridul Phukon etc. But has anyone seen the Case Diary of Parag Das killing? One should see the names of the hostile witnesses in this case. Law is based on witness, statements---be it true or false. Sentences are doled out on the basis of statements of witnesses. The people of Assam should see the case diary of Parag Das killing. It is a bombshell. One should see the false statements of some of the so called 'senior' 'JOURNALISTS' of the State. They belong to the newspaper where late Parag Das worked till the end of his life. Not only that, these fellows hold placards before the camera demanding justice for late Parag Das. This case diary needs to be shown to the public. The people of Assam would know that the state abounds in pseudo-'intellectuals' far more wicked than Mridul Phukon. It would also focus on how low some Assamese 'news'-papers and Assamese journalism has stooped.
milk talukdar's picture

The 90% journalists of Assam are practicing yellow journalism right now. Very poor environment of journalism. No any professionalism. Just criticize govt and get some opportunity. Dear Pallavi, I would like to remind you about Parag Das who is a martyr. So we have to offer Martyr Parag Das instead of Late Parag Das. Thanks for your progressive thinking, though I am not fully agree with you.
Parmita Borah's picture

The Indian Judiciary system is a big joke and nothing else. If an open and shut case like Kasav can be dragged for this long apparently due to "lack of evidence", how can we expect 13 year long case to be resolved so soon. I would agree to Pallavi Barua here, when she expresses that the witnesses, and public in general are to be blamed equally, witnesses for turning hostile and general mass that means us for choosing to ignore such acts.
HimadreeBuragohain Saha's picture

The Indian Judiciary has loopholes due to which the perpetrators and criminals are scott free even after committing such gruesome acts like murders and mob genocides.A case of assassination like Parag Das a brave young journalist cannot be looked down. Young Parag is an example of such young martyrs who loves their country and works and dreams for the welfare of the common citizens and boldly standing against injustice. Now, when such young talents are murdered, that too in broad daylight whom can we blame- the law and judiciary for not being carrying out sufficient evidence to punish such cold-blooded criminals or the general public who were the witnessess in the murder case. It is really a sorry state of affairs that even after 13 years the judiciary failed to charge such criminals for such nasty crimes. As human beings one cannot reject the fact that if one goes and proves the case the particular human being will be finished with life on the very next day. So how can we rely upon our safety? Power of money has sealed the truth of everything. Although one desires to punish the criminal, it is difficult to say when the law and order will be successful in locking up such murderers behind the bars. Thirteen years have already passed. A high time has come for the judiciary and the criminal investigation department to sort out such cases and put the assassinators behind the bars coupled with rigorous punishments. Let the public of Assam rise to the doors of Justice.
Rakesh's picture

Sorry, but i don't have any faith on Indian legal system. it become 100% politicize. this is a time for action rather than discussion. we had lost Parag Da. atleast we can give him a justice...

Pages

Add new comment

Other Contents by Author

Guwahati : There was another high profile kidnapping in Assam. Cement Corporation of India (CCI) official Kailash Nath Jha and his security officer, Madan Kumar Bora were abducted at gun point by suspected militants at a place which falls under Bilai outpost of Bokajan Police Station, about 300 kilometres from Guwahati on Sunday. Police Officials suspect the Karbi Longri National Liberation Front (KLNLF) to be involved in the kidnapping. The KLNLF has very close links to the ULFA as well and hence officials have not ruled out the hand of ULFA in the kidnapping as well. CCI has a cement plant at Bokajan. CCI officials were not available for comments. This high profile kidnapping comes at a...
Way back in the late 1960s, there were two individuals in the then sleepy town of Jorhat who were making and dreaming music in the confines of their homes. The young boys used to go to the local music school, perform in programmes in Assam and create music with rich melodies. Gradually they started capturing the heart and soul of Assam and came to be known as Jitu-Tapan. It so happened that one day the great Mohammad Rafi visited Jorhat in Assam for a show and on the same show there was an orchestra that was presented by the young duo of Assam. Rafi was more than impressed. He called both of them the next day and requested them to teach and compose Assamese songs for him. And “...
Arunachal Pradesh is one of the naturally beautiful states of India situated in the foothills of the Himalayas and there we have the Pakke Wild life sanctuary which is fast developing as a hot spot for Tourists. The River Bhareli (known as Kameng in Arunachal Pradesh) is on the northern and western sides of the sanctuary, to the east is the Pakke River and to the south lies the Nameri National Park of Assam. In this sanctuary the endangered Black Panther species is available. The Wild Life Institute of India (W.I.I.), Dehradun and the forest department of Arunachal Pradesh detected the presence of the Black Panther through camera trapping. This collaborative programme that works for tiger...
Nameri National Park: Aranyak is a biodiversity conservation society of North-East India. It organized a workshop on Eco-Camp of Nameri National Park (a tourist resort) on tiger conservation and its problem in NNP. The Brahamaputra valley in Assam is an important stronghold of the Royal Bengal Tiger (Panthera Tigris) in India and facing serious anthropogenic threats that may lead to extinction in future. The Nameri National Park is one of the designated tiger reserves in Assam. As per the latest tiger census carried out by Forest Department, approximately 37 tigers were found in the park. This accounts for 10.6% of the total tiger population of Assam. The organizer invited a variety of...
Guwahati: Noted tea industrialist Hemendra Prasad Barooah has revealed in a new book about being traced by the ULFA to Philadelphia, about his English acquaintance involved in the Great Train Robbery in the UK, and about the search for Dr Bhupen Hazarika's lost Rolex watch one dark night on a street near Sivasagar. The planter, a multifarious personality, who has remained away from media glare, shares many intimate details of his life with eminent journalist Wasbir Hussain in 'Life and Times: Story of an Assamese Tea Baron', an authorized biography. The book, published by Spectrum Publications, Guwahati/New Delhi, was released by chief minister Tarun Gogoi at a function in a...
Talap : Reports have come in that there was an exchange of fire between ULFA and SULFA in Talap on Thursday . The Sulfa member, Sriman Chetri managed to escape unhurt. This may be precedence for many such instances in the future.
Guwahati : AJYCP, Gorkha Association , have withdrawn the economic blockade that had been in force against Nagaland from last Friday. Post discussions with the Government authorities, the Organsiations have withdrawn the economic blockade.Notably, post the Naga aggression on Assamese villages which had left 3 people dead, the AJYCP, Gorkha Association alongwith the AASU and some other groups had come together to enforce a economic blockade on the roads leading to Nagaland. AASU had earlier withdrawn from the economic blockade on humanitarian grounds on 11thof July 07.
Sibasagar: There was a false alarm at Sibasagar when police received a call informing them that one Mr Dilip Chetri a ULFA member was on his way to the Indian Bank to deposit a large sum of money there. Police and Army personnel descended on the Bank and waited for almost three hours but no one turned up. Investigations are on.
Dhemaji: Floods are in full flow in Dhemaji. Almost 40,000 people have been displaced after a breach in the embankment of the Jiadhol river. 25 villages are reported to be under water and the people have been stranded at various places. People have taken refugee in schools and colleges. Military helicopters are also dropping food and other essentials, officials said on Friday. A government spokesman said that nearly 120 villages in all in Dhemaji are affected since Thursday. This is the second spate of floods to hit Assam this year after the lull in floods last year
Nasscoms had launched the Assessment and Certification Programme (NAC) for the BPO sector which is a great success. Nasscom is now in the process of launching a similar testing and accreditation offer, NAC Tech, for the IT services, according to Mr Kiran Karnik, Chairman of Nasscom. The NAC was launched as a pilot last year for the BPO sector to ensure transformation of a “trainable” workforce into an “employable” workforce. The pilot was first rolled out in Rajasthan where 2,500 people took the NAC test. By the year-end, NAC for BPO will be rolled out in various States, including Tamil Nadu, Gujarat, Chandigarh, Andhra Pradesh, West Bengal and the North eastern...