Skip to content Skip to navigation

The interim budget belied mass expectation

The interim Budget presented in the Indian Parliament was a lack luster budget in recent times. It did nothing to assure anyone any way as to how financial crisis facing the country’s economy would be met. It was merely an excise where statement of account was placed and expenditures were accounted for. Even from where revenues deficit would be met were not explained in details. It also did not specify how new urban jobs would be created to push back unemployment (though allocated 1,31,000 crore for rural sector) situation of the country. The interim budget was a copy book exercise that needs to be followed in normal circumstances. But, is this a normal time? The country is faced with turmoil when business growth is slow and unemployment is mounting and the non-creation of jobs have been creating havoc.

Pranab Mukherjee's speech was almost so uninteresting that half of the Treasury benches were found napping. A few MPs were almost heard snoring while budget speech was read out. There was neither high applause nor booing by the opposition bench which is usual during the budget speech.

This was perhaps first budget in the years where there was almost no change in tax proposals. The Government neither gave any tax concession nor imposed any tax. Naturally corporate sector was not happy as it was expecting withdrawal of tax surcharge. It also expected some concession to Realty and automobile sector. The government felt convinced that nothing needs to be done presently. But it was Pranab Mukherjee who indicated that there could be a third stimulus package for revival of economy further.

The gross tax revenue of the government during 2008-09 is likely to fall short by about Rs 60,000 crore (Rs 600 billion) over the budgeted estimates, as per the Interim Budget for FY'10 presented by acting finance minister Pranab Mukherjee on Monday. It is sad that fiscal deficit is growing in alarming pace and further rise in deficit would be dangerous to the health of the economy.(Rs3,32835 crores deficit in 2009-10)

The shortfall, according to Mukherjee, was 'on account of the government's proactive fiscal measures initiated to counter the impact of global slowdown on the Indian economy.' But there was no indication how this gap would be met. Despite a fair degree of hyped up expectations that had built up in the media, the actual budget was a non-event.

Needless to say, the budget contains nothing that would directly put more (or less) money in anyone's pockets because it was not a budget at all. Any expectations from this event were misplaced. It is a fact that for almost the first time in living memory, many of us will be paying less tax not because tax rates have been lowered but because our real incomes would be lower. (Inflation is expected to shoot up).

Could the government have done more in this interim budget? Normal practice says that it should not have. However, these are obviously not normal times.. Dhirendra Kumar, eminent Financial and Investment expert questioned rightly that why couldn't politicians of the major parties have sat down together and produced a sort of a consensus rescue package that could have gone beyond the constitutional proprieties that bind a vote on account? The answer is that because they are all in election mode. The Share market reacted sharply and went down by more than 300 points of sensex.

Mr. Mukherjee's speech in parliament was little more than the second speech of the election campaign, the first one being the railway budget speech. All of them-government and opposition alike-have gone into full election mode and clearly don't care if the country's economy marks time till about June or so. . In the middle of the worst economic crisis in living memory, our leaders have found more important things to do. How they are going to create more employment was not disclosed. Neither had they tried to empower the youth who are facing bitter joblessness in recent time.

Based on the things Mr. Mukherjee said today, it is difficult to forecast how the real budget will affect the savings and tax situation of the average Indian. He did say at one point that 'In the days of financial stress, tax rates must fall and our ability to pay taxes must rise.' We could not understand what this means . How must our ability to pay taxes rise in days of financial distress? Perhaps it's just an off the cup remark of an astute politician whose heart is not in his job anymore.

The interim budget did nothing, which was expected. Perhaps the political environment is too busy in their own planning and have no time to empower common people to face the crisis the country was facing due to financial downturn.
Author info

gpnarua's picture

Add new comment

Random Stories

AGP protest rally on Sep 19

12 Sep 2015 - 5:55pm | AT News
The opposition Asom Gana Parishad will hold protest rally on September 19 opposing the Centre’s move to give refugee status to the non Muslim Bangladeshi and Pakistani nationals in India.Addressing a...

Arms ammo seized in Dibrugarh

20 Jul 2009 - 9:16am | editor
A huge cache of arms and amminuion were seized during a joint operation by army and police from Mohanbari area at a from forest on Monday. According to information, acting on a tip-off, the team...

VHP role in Silchar: CM

26 Aug 2013 - 8:33pm | AT News
Chief Minister Tarun Gogoi has alleged Vishwa Hindu Parishad’ role in the violence in Silchar where over 50 people have been injured.Talking to reporters Gogoi called BJP, VHP and other associates...

Cop commits suicide at Koinadhara

15 Jul 2012 - 4:50am | editor
In a bizarre incident that rattles Koinadhara, a policeman attached to chief minister’s security committed suicide on Saturday. The tragic incident took place at 10 at night on Saturday when...

Other Contents by Author

Thirty years ago, I was told by Jagdish Phukan, all time great Assamese Entrepreneur cum visionary writer,’ had Amrit been staying back in Assam the state would have transformed into a most livable place in the country’. The remark of Phukan was a personal assessment on his great friend who has been forgotten by most Assamese by now ! The conversation veered round our state when I escorted ,in seventies of last century, the then American Ambassador to India in a visit to Kaziranga and stopped over for a couple of hours in Kamrup Komplex to dine. Amrit was none other than Harvard educated Amrit Baruah who left Assam, in search of mythical El Dorado, back in fifties to USA but...
Ranjan Das, Managing Director of SAP INDIA LTD is no more ! He was 42 years old and considered, by many Corporate Gurus, as the ‘Wizard of the Business Management”. His passing away has created a void in the world of international business. The obituary of Ranjan appeared in National and International electronic & print media all over the world including The WALL Street Journal to Economic Times to quote a few. Assam remained mute spectator to this sad incident, perhaps, in agony; no Assamese knew how to react! He succumbed to heart attack soon after the morning work up on 21st October, at his residence in Bombay. Ranjan was an energetic boy from Guwahati, Assam, with a...
Recently a few well known IT companies have decide not to hire present employees of Satyam. There are few thousand of fresh graduates who have been given appointment letters by Satyam but not yet given the date of joining. They are still waiting to be called. Perhaps all of them would have to forget about their career in Satyam for the new board will hardly be able to absorb any more additional manpower without setting the house in order. So in all practical reasons these young graduates having appointment letter would miss the bus of getting the promised job in Satyam without any fault of them. If these fresh engineers are denied employment by other big IT companies now, would it not...
Assam is going through a very difficult time. Terrorists’ attack one after another has enraged the people of Assam especially the youth. On the top of it due to financial down turn created a situation of depressing environment. Young educated engineering graduates of 2008 are still waiting to receive instructions from employers for the place of joining and date of joining. A few people received appointment letters from the campus interview as early as October 2007 with good salary. They were told to stand by till they graduates officially. The result came out in May 2008. The successful candidates were congratulated and asked to stand by for instructions to join after a few months....
The age of darkness has gripped us. The recent bloody mayhem at Kokrajhar, Guwahati followed by Mumbai is a glaring example of blind and dark age. Who are responsible for these? The responsibility does not rest with a single entity. The responsibility lies with our society who could not consolidate responsibility is with government who could not put in place terror control system and the responsibility lies with politicians who have failed to deliver their assurance to the society. Do they deserve to be our representatives? You have to answer the question from your heart today. Really enough is enough and now is the time for civil society act in unison.Indian Commandos have been able to...
The election of Barrack Obama today as the president of USA symbolises the rise of a new world order. He stands for the change of perception of the people. His emergence signifies that in a modern world skin is less important. What is more important is the capacity to empower humanity. His rise symbolises the synthesis of poor and rich, black and white...
Why terrorism in India is uncontrollable? It is because our civil society does not have guts to protest really. We, rather all encourage it! Never our Government have been able to motivate people to stand together firmly against human rights and human values. In fact, at times, the some Government directly or indirectly encourage violation of human rights. Neither our government, nor our parties nor our institutions...